Monthly Archives: January 2025

The Franchise Playbook: Insider Tips for First-Time Buyers

The Franchise Playbook: Insider Tips for First-Time Buyers written by John Jantsch read more at Duct Tape Marketing

The Duct Tape Marketing Podcast with Alex Smereczniak

In this episode of the Duct Tape Marketing Podcast, I interviewed Alex Smereczniak, serial entrepreneur and CEO of Franzy, a platform transforming franchise discovery and acquisition. Alex has a deep understanding of franchise business strategy, from brand messaging to customer insights, and he shares insider tips on how first-time buyers can successfully navigate the franchise landscape.

During our conversation, Alex revealed the raw truths about franchise ownership, the emotional triggers that drive investment decisions, and how effective marketing research can help buyers identify the right opportunities. He also shed light on the importance of business strategy, customer feedback, and executive insights in building a profitable, scalable franchise.

Alex’s expertise in franchise strategy and customer feedback makes this episode a must-listen for anyone considering franchise ownership. Whether you’re looking for marketing solutions or insights into brand strategy, this conversation provides invaluable guidance on making the right investment.

Key Takeaways:

  • Franchising Is More Than Fast Food: Many people associate franchises with McDonald’s, but the industry extends to home services, fitness, B2B marketing solutions, and beyond.
  • Data-Driven Decision Making: Leveraging customer insights and executive feedback can significantly improve success rates in franchising.
  • The Financial Reality: While franchising offers a lower-risk business model, profitability depends on location, operations, and marketing innovation.
  • Red Flags to Avoid: Be cautious of misleading brand messaging, exaggerated earnings claims, and lack of transparency in marketing research.
  • The Role of Emotional Triggers in Buying a Franchise: Personal goals, lifestyle aspirations, and long-term business strategy should align with the franchise choice.

Chapters:

[01:03] Franchising History
[02:06] Franchise vs. Independent Business
[03:28] Is Franchising Secure?
[05:31] Alex’s Franchise Journey & Franzy
[07:14] Who Invests in Franchises?
[08:34] Franchising is Easier Than You Think
[09:29] Keys to a Profitable Franchise
[14:11] How Franzy Supports Franchising
[17:57] Franchise Red Flags
[19:15] Getting Started with Franzy

John Jantsch (00:00.941)

Hello and welcome to another episode of the Duct Tape Marketing Podcast. This is John Jantsch and my guest today is Alex Smereczniak. Nailed that, I? He’s a serial entrepreneur and the co-founder and CEO of Fransi, a platform revolutionizing franchise discovery and acquisition. They empower aspiring entrepreneurs with transparency, support, and the tools to find the right franchise opportunity. He’s also the co-founder and former CEO of

Alex Smereczniak (00:10.844)

yeah.

John Jantsch (00:29.901)

to you laundry and Laundro lab where he helped build and scale a successful venture backed laundry delivery service and it’s franchise arm as well. So he continues to serve on both boards of those companies. So Alex, welcome to the duct tape marketing podcast.

Alex Smereczniak (00:45.646)

Thanks, John. I’m excited to be on with you today and look forward to talking to all things franchising and how people can get into the wonderful, wacky world of it.

John Jantsch (00:55.607)

Yeah, you know, it’s interesting franchises. I think a lot of people think McDonald’s White Castle’s, you know, some of the really early like food franchises. But in looking at the model, you know, it’s probably been around since the Middle Ages. You know, when, when some king would say, okay, you over there, you get to collect taxes in this region and you submit some of it back to me and you, you know, you get an exclusive on that region. You know, again, I

half kidding, half not kidding, but I mean, it’s really a model that’s been around for the ages, hasn’t it?

Alex Smereczniak (01:29.12)

It has been around forever and it’s more pervasive and I think our everyday lives and most people realize to your point, think McDonald’s, Subway, you don’t think about the moving company that helped you move is probably a franchise or the painting company. It is 8 % of our country’s GDP is produced from the franchise industry and it spans food, hotels, home services, fitness.

John Jantsch (01:35.351)

Yeah. Yeah.

Right, right, Yeah.

Alex Smereczniak (01:54.618)

Coffee, mean you entertainment you name it. There’s probably a franchise model around it

John Jantsch (01:59.917)

Well, yeah, I was going to say the models become so successful that there’s probably not a service where somebody hasn’t at least tried, you know, to get it going. Right. I mean, because I think a lot of people, you know, see the successful model. so, so let’s go there for a minute. You know, is there an inherent advantage, theoretically to a franchise as opposed to somebody just kind of figuring it out on their own.

Alex Smereczniak (02:24.058)

Yeah, so I actually, you know, I’ve done a lot of research on franchising as a whole and two metrics that have jumped out to me before is that, you know, the two year success rate of a franchise business is about 76%. Oh, sorry, sorry. It’s 92 % for the two year success rate for franchising 85 for the five year success rate. That is opposed to 76 % for the two year success rate for just an independent business.

a whopping 50 % success rate after five years. if you look at the two numbers I just shared, 85 % success for franchise businesses after five years, 50 for independent businesses after five years, that’s the answer right there. A lot of people get into franchising because it’s de-risked. It gives people, I don’t want to say a safety net, but you’re working with a community of other people around you that are also building their businesses with you, and then a corporate parent that

John Jantsch (03:06.285)

Yeah, yeah.

Alex Smereczniak (03:19.352)

has proven the model, has marketing resources, has training resources, has tech resources, et cetera, to isolate you to an extent and be valuable.

John Jantsch (03:28.899)

So when the concept or the model itself was really blowing up, probably in the seventies or eighties or so, there were a lot of issues that had the FTC step in. A lot of people were setting up Ponzi schemes. They were taking a hundred thousand dollars from somebody and then the people no support or nothing, what was promised. How would you say the state of sort of regulating that industry has evolved and is it safer?

certainly than it was 50 years ago.

Alex Smereczniak (03:59.802)

There’s two sides to that coin on the regulation around the brand themselves to prevent snake oil salesmen from saying, hey, this is the get rich quick in this whatever concept. The regulation has done a good job there. So every brand has to have what’s called an FDD. It’s called a franchise disclosure document. And it is a 100 to 200 page onerous legal document that covers bankruptcy, litigation, team experience.

John Jantsch (04:10.147)

Right, right.

John Jantsch (04:22.221)

Yes.

Alex Smereczniak (04:27.29)

investment costs, audited financials. mean, it has everything in it and every brand is required to have that. So I, you know, when we got into franchising, was happy to find that the other side of that coin where there still needs to be more regulation is how franchises are sold and bought today. And so a lot of people can go to a McDonald’s and fill out the contact form. They can find something, you know, from a neighbor who might be franchising a concept word of mouth.

A lot of people work through business brokers, franchise brokers, and this part is still very much the Wild West, meaning, if you think about buying a house, your real estate agent had to get licensure, they had to go through training and courses, and they also disclose to you what their commission is going to be. There is zero of that for business brokers, not just in franchising. Any business broker doesn’t need to be licensed. You and I could go be business brokers today.

John Jantsch (04:56.312)

Yeah.

John Jantsch (05:18.263)

Yeah, yeah.

Alex Smereczniak (05:18.99)

And we also don’t have to disclose what percent fee we’re taking and how we’re making money. So there’s also this kind of misalignment to a degree that’s happening there, but that’s changing. Regulation is coming there as well that I think will protect your average consumer and business buyer here in the near future.

John Jantsch (05:35.799)

What would you say you, you started a couple other businesses you franchised or at least participated in franchising those other, did you learn a lot along the way that you’ve now brought to Frenzy?

Alex Smereczniak (05:48.27)

Yeah, honestly, if I hadn’t had the experience previously building a franchise or essentially being my own franchisee running multiple laundromats, I wouldn’t have even had the idea for Franzi. was getting into the franchise world that made me realize, Hey, there’s a big gap here and there’s not a lot of alignment between the brand, brokers, prospects, et cetera. There’s not a good database or set of tools for people to find the right concept for themselves. so.

Part the reason I transitioned out of my last business was to be able to go start this one. It was just a huge gap. It’s kind of like what Zillow did for the real estate market before you had to go through a real estate agent. wasn’t a way to shop online or look at your dream home or your vacation home. And with Frenzy, we’re trying to do exactly that. Be the Zillow for franchising where you can go on your computer at work or go on your computer late at night and say, I’m in Atlanta. I’ve got a hundred K to invest.

What can I afford? Here’s my operational experience. Here are my goals for my family and myself. What are the top five or 10 brands recommended for me based on this information? And that’s exactly what we’ve built with Franzi is you go in, you enter that information and we recommend brands for you. You can deny them or approve them and go further down the conversation with them. And then we facilitate that introduction along with a number of other tools that first time or any business buyer needs.

entity formation, lending, finding the right CPA, etc. We help with all those pieces as well.

John Jantsch (07:13.72)

Yeah.

John Jantsch (07:19.271)

Would you say that there is, and maybe you don’t have enough experience to answer this question, but would you say there’s a distinct different profile of a buyer of a franchise as opposed to somebody who’s just going to go out there and start a business?

Alex Smereczniak (07:32.154)

It’s kind of a cop out answer, but it depends. I just talked to a number of entrepreneurship through acquisition folks. It’s a big trend right now where people are either getting a sponsor to back them to go buy an established business where it’s someone retiring that wants to sell. But some of those ETA folks are looking at buying up the family that owns five Jimmy Johns and wants to sell.

John Jantsch (07:41.677)

Yeah, yeah.

John Jantsch (07:55.191)

Yeah, sure.

Alex Smereczniak (07:57.018)

So you had an ETA person, they’re looking at both independent businesses and franchises as a potential solution. You also have within franchising the large private equity groups that own 50 Jimmy Johns and 20 McDonald’s and they’re massive. But you also have the vice president of a bank who’s in his forties and hates his job and wants to leave and go be his own boss. And he also becomes a McDonald’s franchisee. so your ideal customer profiles, your ICPs vary pretty widely.

John Jantsch (08:08.098)

Yeah.

John Jantsch (08:16.504)

Yeah.

Alex Smereczniak (08:26.99)

they fall pretty solidly into three buckets. It’s your private equity groups, it’s your nine to five veteran that wants to get out, or it’s your family that’s built up a nice business and they’re adding their sixth, seventh, eighth location.

John Jantsch (08:32.301)

Yeah.

John Jantsch (08:43.427)

I guess the part of that question was, know, somebody learns how to be a plumber and they start a plumbing business. lot of franchisees owners, mean, they don’t know a thing about the actual business. Like they’ve never run a restaurant, right? You know, they’ve never run a gym, but they like the idea of not really needing to know that because the system’s figured out. I mean, is that a fair statement?

Alex Smereczniak (09:06.714)

Yeah, I franchising is a lot more accessible. It goes back to the success rates I mentioned earlier. There’s a reason it’s almost double. You know, the success rate is almost double for those getting into franchises versus going at it alone. You have training wheels essentially in franchising, but eventually when you start going from one unit to two to two to five, five to 10 training wheels are off and you’re, booking it downhill. You got some momentum behind you and you know what you’re doing at that point, but

John Jantsch (09:30.413)

Hehehe

Alex Smereczniak (09:33.55)

You had to cut your teeth at some point, just like anything. You got to learn those first year or two and get yourself in the business.

John Jantsch (09:39.693)

So talk a little bit about, and again, maybe you haven’t owned enough franchises to have this opinion, but talk a little bit about the profitability or the ability to really make money in a franchise. One of the knocks you sometimes hear, whether it’s true or not, is that there are people owning a couple of subways and not making as much as they would in a regular job, for example. Is that?

Is that a true statement? You really need to actually be able to scale this thing to a certain point or is that more the nature of picking the right franchise?

Alex Smereczniak (10:16.888)

Yeah, so think it depends on a number of things. Your individual goal, if it’s a retail business, the location you decide on in the market around it, how competitive is it? How much of a need is this? A lot of it depends on the operator. You could have the best business in the world, but if you’re not there at all, you only show up once a month and you’re not checking in on things, it’s going to be run poorly. So like any other business, the franchise still requires thoughtfulness around the location, being a good operator, et cetera.

to be more pointed. There is a franchise for just about every kind of goal and need. There’s one that you can be a basically buy yourself a job, get a bucket and a mop. A lot of people don’t realize UPS is a franchise where you franchise the route, but you are the delivery driver. And some people like that because they’re buying themselves a job, but they also have the freedom and the flexibility of being an owner, even though they might only be profited.

John Jantsch (10:57.95)

yeah. Yeah.

Alex Smereczniak (11:12.356)

profiting 40 to 100K a year. That’s fine. They just like that they report to themselves essentially.

John Jantsch (11:17.823)

Yeah, plus they don’t have to depend on dozens of teenagers actually running the store,

Alex Smereczniak (11:22.618)

So you’ve got, you’ve got things from the delivery driver to, you know, a commercial cleaning business all the way up to you’re building a $4 million sky zone, you know, in indoor trampoline park and the EBITDA, the profit is substantially higher, you know, half a million plus. There is such, that’s what’s so great about franchising is it’s so accessible and there’s something at each end of the spectrum and each range, each risk tolerance, each goal.

John Jantsch (11:36.673)

Right.

John Jantsch (11:51.915)

Are there, are there some, hot kind of categories right now?

Alex Smereczniak (11:57.946)

Yeah. So home services is really big right now because it’s, really accessible. You don’t need to build this multimillion dollar location. You also don’t have to be as right about the location because you have this huge territory. And so if you’re doing gutter cleaning or window cleaning, or, um, there was an interesting one I saw the other day, you know, it’s, it’s a Christmas decorations or the franchise for, and so it’s, you have some of these things that are more accessible, less upfront costs and investment.

John Jantsch (12:20.671)

Okay, yeah.

Alex Smereczniak (12:27.242)

but still can generate pretty substantial revenues and profit to the point where it could replace a lot of people’s annual salaries. And now again, it’s your thing, it’s your business, you have more flexibility and freedom and more fulfilling.

John Jantsch (12:34.232)

Yeah.

John Jantsch (12:41.175)

Yeah, it’s interesting too, in home services, you know, used to be you’d call a remodeler or handyman and they’d come out and look at what you needed. But now it’s like, my garage door, I need that fixed. You know, here’s somebody that puts in 75 garage doors, you know, every week, you know, I’m going to call them. And so it’s, you see the, especially the home services getting really, really nichey, don’t you?

Alex Smereczniak (13:01.402)

Yeah, that’s one of my favorite ones. You actually just mentioned is there’s a concept called the garage Kings. It’s a franchise and Damon, Damon John, the guy from shark tank actually use them unintentionally and did his own Instagram reel of it because he just was so blown away by the quality of the service. But to your point, it’s cause garage Kings only does garage. They epoxy, epoxy the floors. put up shelving and storage.

John Jantsch (13:10.115)

Sure.

Alex Smereczniak (13:24.856)

And it’s a phenomenal business. You don’t need a ton of equipment and the average territory does over a million dollars a year in revenue and it’s a franchise.

John Jantsch (13:31.543)

Yeah. So talk a little bit about kind of your approach and what, you know, if somebody’s out there looking, thinking I want to do this, you know, what role do you fill for that person that’s kind of, cause just as we’ve talked about, I mean, it’s, know, the, if you just went out there and typed in franchise, you know, it’s going to be like, okay, let’s start with 6 billion, you know, ideas. So, so kind of where do you, where do you fit in the search?

Alex Smereczniak (13:56.282)

Yeah.

Yep. we’re, we’re, uh, you know, the way that we describe ourselves as reeducation. So if you’re a first timer franchising one-on-one, what is an FDD? What is a franchise disclosure document? What are the terms I should be familiar with? And then what should I be thinking about as far as affordability, time commitment, what’s available? You know, those key buckets. We also are a resource for people that are buying their 10th business or that private equity group that I mentioned that might be looking for the right concept to go buy 20 of.

And so we do, we have tools for kind of each one of those buckets, but let’s follow that person through the journey of, don’t know what I’m doing, know, what the hell I’m doing. So we help with the education and getting people comfortable. Once you come to Franzy, we also start to help you get pre-qualified with lenders that we’ve partnered with. So right away, you know, just like buying a house or buying a car, lot of these, a lot of these sites tell you that now. And so it helps refine your search immediately. There’s 4,000 brands in the United States. Well, once you fill out your pre-qual,

John Jantsch (14:47.585)

Yeah, here’s what I can afford. Yeah, yeah.

Alex Smereczniak (14:57.486)

Well, now here’s a thousand that you can financially afford. All right. What areas are you looking in? All right. Here’s 300 that are available. You see where this is going to goes from 4,000 to a thousand to 300. And then we start to ask a lot of questions about what’s your, what are your family’s goals? What’s your risk tolerance? What’s your operational experience? And then what are your hobbies and interests so that we actually, you know, we find a business that resonates with you and that you like. By the time we do all of that and we’re using AI to do this, there’s also coaching with franchise experts on our team that you can speak with.

By the time you have those conversations and you fill out these surveys, we’ve got it down to a pretty high degree of confidence that here’s this five brand recommendation for you. One of these five brands is going to be a perfect fit. And if it’s not, we’ve got another couple hundred that we’ve narrowed it down to that we can continue to feed and teach our model to make sure that this is the absolute best business for John from those four factors I mentioned. It satisfies his risk tolerance. We know he can afford it. We know it’s available in his area.

and it fits his goals and his interests.

John Jantsch (15:58.819)

I’m curious, what’s the, and it probably varies a little bit, but what’s the process from, okay, you’ve given me those five brands to like somebody actually starting a business once they decide. mean, is that a year long process?

Alex Smereczniak (16:12.418)

It depends on the type of business. So with Franzy as an example, let’s say we get to the five and you’re excited about three of them. So we’ll introduce you to those three. have relationships with all these brands. you start to go through their process and build a rapport with them. They’re interviewing you to make sure you’d be a good franchisee as part of their system and vice versa. You’re interviewing them to make sure that this is a 10 year commitment you want to make and an investment of time and money that you want to make. And so let’s say.

You narrow it down to one, you love it, you’re married to this idea, you want to become a franchisee and they feel the same way. You sign a franchise agreement. Well, sorry, let me back up a second. As soon as you start matching with a brand and you have that first conversation, the average sales cycle is 90 to 120 days. There’s a lot of calls back and forth. You eventually fly to the headquarters to see a day in the life and meet the team. That’s 60 to 90 days.

John Jantsch (16:55.971)

Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah.

Alex Smereczniak (17:03.63)

From there, if it’s a retail business, can definitely expect 12-ish months because you have to find a site, do build out. There’s a lot more to a retail business. If it’s a home services business, which is why they’re so hot right now, is you can get a truck and do some training and you’re locked and loaded in two months, baby. Let’s go.

John Jantsch (17:09.133)

Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah.

John Jantsch (17:15.329)

Yeah, yeah, yeah, get a get a truck and get it wrapped. Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah. As and I’m sure you’ve seen all these and so you advise some people, but I’m guessing you probably only work with reputable folks. But are there some red flags that somebody should that you would tell people, hey, if they’re telling you this?

Alex Smereczniak (17:39.514)

Yeah, anyone that’s promising you’re going to get rich. Be very wary of that because again, at end of the day, you’re running a business. It’s still your business and no one can guarantee that you’re going to be successful. Even yourself. I mean, you have to get the right side. You got to be a good operator. All the things we mentioned. So look for people promising things. You got to be careful of that. Look for stores closing. And so we have tons of data over the last five, five years on Franzy. So if you see a trend of, hey, they opened 300 stores and then 50 shut down and they only opened a net new, you know, 10 over that.

John Jantsch (17:42.497)

Yeah, right. Right.

John Jantsch (17:47.555)

Yeah.

John Jantsch (18:00.748)

right, yeah yeah.

Alex Smereczniak (18:09.53)

What’s going on here? You know, that’s the question you should be asking. Any litigation, the obvious one is litigation or bankruptcy. And then checking the item 19 is critical. That’s where the audited financials are in the FDD. If you see, you know, if a business is doing well, they’re going to want to brag about it, right? They’re going to want to show the financials and look at our stores, make a ton of money. And so could you, if they’re hiding it or they’re doing weird adjustments and, adjusted

John Jantsch (18:14.902)

Yeah.

John Jantsch (18:24.493)

Huh.

John Jantsch (18:33.677)

Yeah.

Alex Smereczniak (18:38.774)

EBITDA and adjusted revenue and goofy things like that. That’s a flag to at least press on and double click on.

John Jantsch (18:39.98)

Yeah. Yeah.

John Jantsch (18:47.139)

So how does the process with you? mean, is it fairly much an online tool? I know you have a couple like the Fit Score and the Connect Tool. Is that all something you just go to your website, create an account, and kind of start doing on their own?

Alex Smereczniak (19:03.822)

Yeah, so the whole goal of Franzy is going to make this really accessible to anyone. And so you create an account, free to do, it’s free for anyone using our site all the way through. We make money if an individual buys a franchise, then the franchisor pays us kind of like a real estate agent. But we’ll help you through finding the right fit, which is part of AI powered, part of the product we’ve built. We help you with pre-qualification.

John Jantsch (19:23.426)

Yeah, yeah.

Alex Smereczniak (19:32.014)

We help you with all the data and the research that you need to make a confident decision. And then we also do have expert coaches on our team, people that have owned franchise businesses or that were franchisors that will talk you through any hesitations, questions, concerns that you have to get you familiar with everything you need to be successful. The really cool part about what we do is once we introduce you to brands that we’ve vetted,

John Jantsch (19:48.824)

Nice.

Alex Smereczniak (19:58.21)

We become a virtual coach in your corner. So part of the sales process is you have this overview call, a unit economics call, stuff that’s kind of intimidating if it’s your first time. And even if it’s not, it’s a lot of work and you want a sounding board. So we’ve built all these resources to say, Hey, John, you have an overview call coming up. Here’s what to expect and some pre-read materials to prepare yourself. And also here’s some curated questions we recommend you ask on that call so that you’re making sure you’re addressing your risk, your hesitations and other things.

that you expressed to us during this whole onboarding process. And then you can talk to us as a person as well that whole time whenever you want. A long answer, but soup to nuts, research, coaching, your qualification and matching you with the right fit brand.

John Jantsch (20:36.14)

Awesome.

John Jantsch (20:44.043)

Yeah. Well, and I think one of the real advantages, while obviously you want somebody to move forward because that’s how you get paid, you don’t really care which one they move forward with. So you’re not really pushing one horse or another, you?

Alex Smereczniak (20:56.122)

I’m glad you brought that up because it’s one of the reasons we started this is a lot of folks that have gone through, you brokers, other channels don’t realize they’re being presented only brands that have agreed to pay to play in the background. We have this inventory of thousands. We’re, your point, we’re indifferent. Our success fee is a flat dollar amount versus a percent of the commission. As you can imagine, if one brand has a, you an $80,000 franchise, and one has 40,000 and I’m paid a percentage of that.

John Jantsch (21:23.181)

Right, yeah. Sure. Yeah.

Alex Smereczniak (21:23.706)

People are inherently going to try to push you to the 80, even though it might not be in your best interest. So we cut that out of the model entirely and said, we don’t care if it’s 80 or 40, we get paid X. So we really want to find the right fit for John because ultimately that’s going to cause him to buy the second one, the third one, increase his chance of success, tell his friends to check out Franzy, et cetera. It’s in everyone’s best interest if we all get a line.

John Jantsch (21:44.907)

Awesome. there somewhere, I appreciate you taking a moment to stop by the Duct Tape Marketing Podcast. Is there somewhere you’d send people to connect with you and learn more? know we’ve talked about Franzy, FRNZY.com. Anywhere else you want to send people?

Alex Smereczniak (22:01.166)

No, think Franzy is the best place to get started. then if you can, if my complicated last name shows up, connect with me on LinkedIn. I’m happy to answer anyone’s franchise related questions or help them in any way that I can as they think about becoming an entrepreneur, buying a business, or just curious about franchise things in general.

John Jantsch (22:17.219)

And did I get close on your last name?

Alex Smereczniak (22:20.314)

So you were close on like the actual authentic pronunciation. The Americanized is Smrznak. The Polish version is Smiercznek, which is closer to what you said.

John Jantsch (22:26.467)

Yeah. Yeah. I was trying to get that neck in there, know, part, but I have an Austrian name that has a lot of consonants at the end of it. So I’m very sensitive to trying to get people’s names right. Awesome. Awesome. Well, I appreciate you stopping by the Duct Tape Marketing Podcast. Hopefully we’ll run into you one of these days out there on the road.

Alex Smereczniak (22:45.402)

Well, I appreciate it. You were close.

Alex Smereczniak (22:54.754)

Yep, thanks again, John.

 

 

How to Adapt, Thrive, and Stay Human in an AI-Driven World

How to Adapt, Thrive, and Stay Human in an AI-Driven World written by John Jantsch read more at Duct Tape Marketing

The Duct Tape Marketing Podcast with John Jantsch

In this episode of the Duct Tape Marketing Podcast, we dive into the evolving world of marketing in 2025, where artificial intelligence (AI) is reshaping how businesses operate. The discussion highlights the importance of balancing cutting-edge AI tools with timeless human elements like emotional intelligence (EI) and authentic connection. As marketing trends accelerate and marketing tools multiply, the challenge lies in leveraging these advancements strategically while staying true to your brand voice and fostering personalization.

AI in marketing has the power to disrupt industries, but as discussed, it’s critical to focus on strategic marketing and storytelling to maintain authenticity. The conversation also explores hyper-personalization, marketing automation, and how businesses can navigate the fast-paced evolution of marketing tools while creating meaningful relationships with their customers.

By blending cutting-edge AI with timeless human values, businesses can adapt, thrive, and stay human in an AI-driven world. As marketing evolves, success will depend on leveraging personalization, EI, and a clear brand voice to cut through the noise.

Key Takeaways:

  • Strategy Before Technology
    Without a solid marketing strategy, shiny new AI tools can lead to faster failure. Focus on aligning AI applications with your business goals to maximize impact.
  • The Role of Emotional Intelligence (EI)
    As AI democratizes intelligence, EI becomes a key differentiator. Skills like empathy, communication, and contextual understanding are more important than ever in strategic marketing.
  • The Power of Storytelling in Marketing
    Storytelling remains a vital way to humanize your brand and connect with audiences. AI can’t replicate personal experiences, making your authentic stories a unique advantage.
  • Brand Voice and Personalization
    Define and maintain your brand voice to stand out in an AI-saturated landscape. Use AI-driven hyper-personalization to deliver tailored messages that resonate with your audience.
  • Navigating AI Disruption
    AI is transforming marketing trends and tools across content creation, design, and personalized sales. However, businesses that prioritize the human element in marketing will create stronger, more authentic connections.

Chapters:

[01:15] AI vs Previous Tech Excitement
[03:25] Approaching AI Strategically
[05:02] Adopting the Right Mindset Around AI
[10:47] The Human Element Stands Out
[13:04] Importance of Storytelling for Your Brand
[13:49] AI’s Impact on Marketing
[16:08] The Future of Personalization
[18:55] Marketing Focus for 2025

John Jantsch (00:00.686)

Hello and welcome to another episode of the Duct Tape Marketing Podcast. This is Jon Jantsch and I think I’m kind of the guest today because my host today is Sarah Ney, CEO of Duct Tape Marketing and she’s gonna, we’re just gonna have a conversation about some of the things going on in the world of marketing. I’ve said before, I think 2025 is going to be a year to remember in terms of change. I’ll say that next year too, I bet.

But I think the pace of change that I think we’re seeing right now, just in the first couple of weeks of January, it’s kind of flooring me. And I think it’s going to be tough to keep up. So strap in, hang on, and here we go, sir.

Sara Nay (00:40.285)

And we were just having a discussion with some of our team about how we’re always, you know, looked at it, staying in top of marketing trends. And that’s been the position of duct tape marketing for a while. And right now we feel like we’re sprinting more than we have before with all the advancements. And that’s a lot of what we’re going to talk about today. So thanks for letting me steal the host seat. I want to start with a question. Sure.

John Jantsch (00:46.574)

You

John Jantsch (00:58.368)

Yeah. Well, I can, throw in a joke, a lame joke. So R and D now stands for run and dash.

Sara Nay (01:03.805)

I it. Well, I’m going to start with a question. You’ve been in the game, the marketing game for quite some time now. So you were involved when websites, everyone started building websites and getting online. And also when social media became a thing and everyone was talking about how that’s going to change the whole entire industry. And so right now, obviously we’re going through a lot of conversation and discussion and excitement around AI and everything that’s evolving there. So I’m curious, how does right now feel the same?

than some of those different excitement phases that have happened or developments that have happened over the years. And also on the other end, how does it feel a bit different this time or does it feel different?

John Jantsch (01:41.964)

Yeah. So, I mean, in some ways it feels if there’s a same, it’s fundamentally what we’re here to do as marketers. I don’t think it’ll ever change. And so a lot of the changes that came along were like, wait, we have a new way to interact with customers. We have a new platform to be found. Customers, you know, have a different way to buy from us. So those were, those were kind of in a lot of ways, incremental changes, significant ones for a lot of folks.

In terms of the change with what AI is bringing, I think it’s much more foundational. It certainly feels very different. And I think partly because it impacts so many areas of a business. A lot of the website was kind of a marketing thing, whereas AI is impacting finance, it’s impacting customer service, it’s impacting certainly all the marketing functions. And ultimately it’s impacting consumers and what they’re able to do greatly.

I just feel like this is a, you know, I’ve heard some people say this, it might be kind of cliche, but you know, this is almost like, this is almost like, you know, the industrial revolution, like all these machines, you know, came along that automated, you know, manual labor that, you know, that, that really displaced a lot of jobs and started creating the, you know, the knowledge economy. And I think this is a bit more like that. This is going to fundamentally shift how we work.

Sara Nay (03:04.059)

Yeah, absolutely. And the school system, a lot of it was built from that era as well. And so I’ve heard a lot of conversation about, you know, potentially AI adjusting how we actually teach our children in school as well. Who needs it? It’s done for you. A lot of what you’ve spoken about over the years is strategy before tactics. And now a lot of people are talking about strategy before technology. And so I’m just curious your take on there’s, there’s a lot of shiny objects in AI.

John Jantsch (03:08.546)

Yeah. Yeah.

John Jantsch (03:14.722)

Yeah, no more math, right? Who needs math? Who needs learned math, right?

John Jantsch (03:24.557)

Yes.

John Jantsch (03:31.278)

Yeah.

Sara Nay (03:31.867)

There’s a lot of, every time I check my email, there’s 10 different tools that are being recommended for me that relate to AI. And so I think a lot of people are getting sucked into just doing things and figuring out how it works, but not necessarily taking a step back and saying, how could this apply to my business? How could I approach this strategically? So what would your advice be there for someone that needs to get out of the shiny object syndrome and focus on the strategy behind it?

John Jantsch (03:54.498)

Well, I think there’s a real danger in not. In fact, think strategy is more important. And here’s why. It’s like taking somebody who used to ride a bike. You know, got a helmet, you’re riding the bike, you’re probably okay if you crash unless you’re like on a mountain or something, right? But now we’re going to put somebody in the seat of a Lamborghini without a seatbelt, without a helmet. We’re going to say, drive really fast. And if they don’t…

If they’re on the right road, if they don’t have the right map, if they don’t have the right skills, you know, they’re just going to, they’re just going to die faster. I know that’s sort of dramatic, but I think that that’s what’s going to happen from a marketing state, from a business. If your strategy is wrong, if your messaging is wrong, if your product market fit is wrong, you’re just going to fail faster now. So you might succeed faster as well.

Sara Nay (04:29.233)

Yeah.

Sara Nay (04:43.648)

Yeah.

John Jantsch (04:46.606)

But if you don’t have the right strategy in place, it’s going to say, here’s the path we’re going to take. There’s a real danger in just having a whole lot of technology that’s going to get you there faster.

Sara Nay (04:57.649)

Yeah, absolutely. What about the mindset shift too? Cause there definitely are different sides of things. People are like AI is the future, stuff’s changing quickly. This is the best thing ever. But there’s also the other side of things where people are like, I’m terrified as where we’re going, we’re going to lose all these jobs. And so what about adopting the right mindset to be able to advance with these different tools?

John Jantsch (05:04.824)

Yeah.

John Jantsch (05:10.424)

Sure. Yeah.

John Jantsch (05:16.13)

Well, I think there’s legitimate fear. There are a lot of jobs that are going to be displaced, a lot of positions, a lot of skills that are not going to be that important. mean, when you think about it, I now have the world’s smartest human beings, the world’s greatest IQ at my disposal. All of sudden being smarter is not going to be an advantage necessarily because we can tap that computing power.

so the mindset shifts, I think, I think it’s a two level, certainly at the leadership level, you have to embrace it. You have to train your folks. You have to get them ready. And I think at the manager, the skilled, you know, person working in an organization, you know, they have to realize that their job is probably not, any more about doing technical things. it is going to be about managing the path that those technical things are being done on. So.

You know, that might not be a fit for everybody who really likes to get in there and crunch the numbers and analyze the data. You know, instead of really looking at like, I need to be really good at reading actuary tables, for example, you actually need to be really good at analyzing this amazing output that you’re going to get from these tools and managing and orchestrating the output that you get and making sense of it and contextualizing it. And that’s probably a different skill set.

You know, before we got on the call, I was, and I give Lisa Adams full credit for this. her up on LinkedIn. If you want to find out some somebody who’s really doing some great things in AI. But she, she said this statement. I think we’ve been saying it for a long time. Strategy is going to be more important. The human element is going to be more important, but she, just nails it with this. As AI democratizes IQ, EQ is going to become more important.

Some people call them soft skills, but emotional quotient. The ability to bring emotion, the ability to bring reality into who you’re trying to market you, to understand your customers, to understand the context in which your customers are trying to solve their problems. Those are things that humans with high EQ are very, very good at.

John Jantsch (07:33.058)

you can take it farther. mean, AI is democratizing reach. So community is going to be more important. Like as we can like spam more people, you know, communicating is going to be more important as AI just makes it so easy for anybody who’s never written two words, or put two sentences together, can now create, you know, theoretically create long form content, you know, having that personal connection with your clients is going to become more important. So those are all things that

If you were going to go read a book or take a course on EQ, those are the kinds of things, listening, empathy are the kinds of things that they would talk about. And I think those are going to be the things that those are going to be the skills that are going to be valued in the job market moving forward.

Sara Nay (08:19.611)

Yeah, absolutely. And so we’ve talked about this a lot, you and I too, it’s right now it’s we’re not thinking about AI is replacing jobs. It’s helping us do different or better or higher level work. And so think that also sums up what you were saying there. We’re not like firing our whole team and letting them go because we’re bringing a bunch of AI. but we are helping them all elevate and us ourselves elevate, you know, to, focus on the strategic thinking and the creativity and the collaboration and the EQ elements that you talked about there as well.

John Jantsch (08:48.844)

Yeah, and sadly, there will be people that are looking at that way. Look, I can have all these agents and I don’t have to have any people. I saw somebody post on LinkedIn, the $3 billion company with only three employees. you know, those get headlines, those get clicks. But, you know, frankly, it is going to displace the positions or the functions inside of organizations. you know, certainly people with high EQ, I think, will

who can adapt to kind of a new way to work, I think will thrive. And there will be some, you know, just like everything. I mean, when the automobile came along, you know, when the factories came along, mean, different jobs got displaced when the computer came along, you know, different jobs got displaced. And, you know, the, the, it ultimately, you know, new jobs were created, new education was created, new training was created for people to, you know, to change the skills. But that’s

Sara Nay (09:20.669)

Yeah.

John Jantsch (09:44.482)

You know, it’s never great for somebody that, you know, all their life has done a certain type of job and now they’re being told, you have to, you have to work differently than you have your whole life. But you know, that that’s come really with, with even incremental changes, you know, over time in the workplace.

Sara Nay (09:53.776)

No.

Sara Nay (10:00.197)

Yeah, I think it’s really important. I read something the other day about the mind shift with AI and what you were talking about there is like, you really have to have a growth mindset with this thing. You have to be eager to learn and expand and grow as a human to be able to get the full capabilities of AI. And I think that’s a good, good way to think about it as well.

John Jantsch (10:07.918)

Totally. Totally.

John Jantsch (10:16.504)

Yeah. And I’ll acknowledge it’s exhausting. but you, you know, I think particularly at the speed, you know, that we’re moving right now, but you’re absolutely right. You have to have that gross mindset and, and it’s tough because I mean, it means you have to do things that are not comfortable. Maybe, you know, there, there’s a lot of people that you mentioned this idea that AI seems really frightening and kind of techie. And so there’s just.

Sara Nay (10:18.993)

Yeah.

John Jantsch (10:43.468)

You know, some folks that that’s, know, that’s not their comfort zone, but it’s a matter of, don’t mean this in a really negative sounding way, but, I don’t think we have much choice.

Sara Nay (10:55.079)

Yeah.

Another area I want to dive into a bit more is you mentioned the human element a little bit more and making personal connections with your clients. And so with the evolution of AI right now, we’re seeing people are producing more content. There’s chat bots online, you’re, you know, you’re getting cold outreach, direct outreach from AI tools. And so there’s a lot of stuff that feels very automated. LinkedIn comments is another example where it just feels very automated. So how can companies stand out from that noise by doing things such as, you know, building trust, building brand actually

John Jantsch (11:07.491)

Yeah.

John Jantsch (11:25.635)

Yeah.

Sara Nay (11:26.675)

connecting with people. So what are some examples to stand out from the noise?

John Jantsch (11:30.894)

Well, I think for a lot of marketers, particularly, you have to really understand your brand voice. mean, you have to have a brand voice. mean, that’s one of your differentiators. Duct tape marketing is quite often seen by people as very practical, down to earth, plain spoken. And that’s a brand voice that we’ve spent a lot of time developing. And shame on us if we use some of the automation tools to not sound like us.

so, so I think that’s really, you know, I feel like we’re very empathetic. think we’re very caring about what we do, and care about the people that we serve. and that comes out, I think in the content that we produce and, you know, it is really tempting to say, look, I can do a, I can automate somebody having a hundred LinkedIn comments, you know, spread all over the place. Well, first off, it probably is counter.

to what you’re trying to do because you know, you and I have laughed about it. You see these comments on your LinkedIn posts and it’s clearly, you know, that was just AI generated and, and, you know, it really actually kind of makes you want to ban that person, you know? And so it’s certainly not doing any value for them. But I think what it just means is it’ll get easier to spot something that is both AI generated and something that is actually authentically generated.

I think you’ll get, I think the gap between those two is going to get even larger. And so spending the time to say, Hey, here’s who I really am. And this is how I talk. And maybe I don’t use punctuation here, you know, whatever, whatever it is, that is your brand voice. I think just understand it and stay true to it. And I know there are a lot of people talking about, you can train AI to do that. but I can spot it.

Sara Nay (13:18.619)

Yeah. think one of the easiest ways to spot an actual human producing content for me versus AI, one of the best ways I can see is storytelling. If someone’s talking about their actual personal experiences, I think that’s an easy way to spot. do you think there’s going to be an increased importance of storytelling as a brand and also humans representing the brand as well?

John Jantsch (13:27.458)

Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah.

John Jantsch (13:39.148)

Yeah. Yeah. I think storytelling has actually been, it’s been hot for 10 years. know, I mean that idea in marketing, but I think you’re right. It’s now going to be a key differentiator. mean, AI can’t make up that case story or that example of, know, what happened, you know, on the day at work in your actual office can’t be made up. And so, you know, I think that that’s a lot of ways going to be a huge differentiator.

Sara Nay (14:04.081)

Yeah, absolutely. Do you think there’s a specific area of marketing that’s being shaken up the most right now? So SEO, paid, any channels that are being shaken up the most right now?

John Jantsch (14:12.653)

Yeah.

John Jantsch (14:16.194)

Well, I think the content one was the first one that of course, you know, when people woke up and went, wait, I hate writing content. You mean I can just put this in this thing and it’ll spit out 700 words? I mean, the real temptation, you know, was first there because it seemed so easy. It seemed, you know, too good to be true, right? And so people certainly jumped in there. So it, now a lot of people are starting to realize the backlash of that and the fallacy of, you know, of that just being able to produce content. So that was the first area though that clearly got disrupted.

I would say the next one is clearly going to be coming in the creative space, the design, the video, the editing. mean, those are things that, again, I don’t think there’s too many people out there going to Dali and producing images for everything, but certainly it’s not far away and they’re not only having video and audio editing tools that work quite well, they’re going to have video and audio creation.

tools that are going to work, you know, to the, to the level where you could actually put in a script and it will actually create an entire video for you. So I think there’ll be some disruption there. Again, I think that’s one of those things that now all of a sudden there’s the, know, there’s a lot of things that AI tools can do. And, you know, I think the differentiator is going to be somebody looking at it and saying, you know, with our brand voice in mind, with our brand promise in mind.

what should it do? And so, you know, there are things, you know, I had somebody that wanted to have an AI bot interview me for a podcast, you know, for, for example, I was like, well, first off, I wasn’t interested, but secondly, I was like, why would anybody, you know, think that was a good idea? But, you know, there are a lot of things that people do because they look at it they go, look, if we connect this together and this connect and people get really excited about that.

Sara Nay (16:01.852)

Yeah.

John Jantsch (16:10.382)

But I think we have to stay real and say, okay, from a practical sense, what would be best experience for our clients?

Sara Nay (16:17.723)

Yeah, absolutely. And that’s why we’ve been really focused on recently in our conversations is what’s a good use case. Like, why are we exploring this? How can we actually make a difference with that? And I think that’s an important thing to keep in mind. Another area that I’ve heard you talk about a little bit is hyper personalization in terms of communication. And so it’s not going to be just about mass content to everyone that follows you. Like we have an opportunity to get a lot more focused in what we’re saying to specific people. So I would love to just hear your, your insights and what do you think the opportunity there is for 2025?

John Jantsch (16:47.352)

Well, for a lot of smaller businesses, the opportunity, mean, personalization has been there. Let’s face it, since email service providers came along and you could say, John, inside an email, that’s a level of personalization that’s been there forever. But what AI does is gives us easier access to a lot of data. So for instance, not only do I know your first name,

I know your LinkedIn profile and I know the last five things you’ve posted about. And that can actually be brought into a data set, you know, keeping all privacy, you know, things in mind that can be brought into a data set that would allow me to say, Hey, here are four products we sell. You talked about this. I’m going to send you an email on Tuesday morning at seven o’clock, because that’s when you post all the time. And I know you’re around on your computer. So I’m going to send you that email and I’m going to talk about.

not only a certain product that we have that I think would be a fit for you, but the problem that you uniquely identified that it solves for you. So that’s the promise of it. Now, the challenge of course is, you know, a lot of small businesses don’t have access to that data. A lot of larger organizations certainly are way ahead in that game. but

Segmenting and personalizing is something that, you know, a lot of the tool sets are going to start making easier in the very near future. And I think it’s, you know, a lot of what we have to do as marketers is informed by behavior that other companies are doing, that people get used to. And so when people start expecting that you’re going to understand, you know, what they need, or you’re going to understand it.

They already bought that product. They’re going to be less tolerant about, you know, your kind of one size fits all kind of promotion.

Sara Nay (18:41.275)

Yeah. On the sales side of things, I’m using a tool right now to prepare for sales calls where it basically brings in someone’s disc profile based on their LinkedIn. And it helps me understand how to sell to that unique individual, how to get their attention. Should I stay very high level or should I get down into the weeds? And so that’s just an example of more personalized sales. I know you were talking a lot about marketing, but marketing and sales go together. So

John Jantsch (18:57.485)

Right.

John Jantsch (19:05.582)

Yeah. I, it’s funny that I use that same tool. Of course, I just did a Google meet with somebody and it actually popped up in the Google meet and said, here’s how to talk with that person. So it was pretty, pretty cool. Yeah. I suspect it does in zoom. I didn’t, I’ve never done it, but I, that was the first time I’d seen it.

Sara Nay (19:16.414)

well.

Sara Nay (19:23.724)

Well, we’re at the top of our time about so any final thoughts just on the topic of 2025, what people should be focusing on right now in marketing.

John Jantsch (19:31.436)

Well, you said probably the one that’s the biggest, know, is, is continue to evolve. I mean, this is not going to stop. You’re not going to catch up necessarily. So continue, you know, to grow, continue to commit to growth. And I don’t think you have to, I don’t think you have to throw your hands up and say, I have to learn everything about this. Follow a couple of good people, focus on one new tool or one new use case, you know, a month.

or something so that you’ll start understanding it and start making it a priority for your teams to start, to continue to grow, to continue to learn these things so that you can actually explore them together and really start to get that mindset cemented about how we have to work with this new set of tools and technology that we’re all going to have available, whether we like it or not.

Sara Nay (20:24.893)

And I would add one more to I’ve learned a lot from just connecting and masterminding with other people that are doing really interesting things with AI and so I would also encourage you on top of what John just shared to form a mini mastermind group with some peers and share use cases and how you’re both all exploring the different tools as well because I think you can just learn a lot from others because we’re all just figuring it out right now.

John Jantsch (20:32.622)

100%.

John Jantsch (20:46.668)

We ought to do that. Why don’t we create a membership type of program where you can join and we’ll give you a use case once a month and kind of collaborate as a group in a live training or something. If that sounds interesting to you, send me an email, because that’s something we might actually work on. think that would be a really cool thing. So it’s just John at Duct Tape Marketing if you think that that idea of a collaboration membership.

around AI so you can learn in real time. Like there’s no way to create a course on AI because it’s changing so fast, but kind of having a monthly accountability group where you’re working on a use case might actually be kind of cool. So let’s do that, sir.

Sara Nay (21:26.609)

Let’s do it. heard it here first. We’ll keep it as practical as possible. So thanks, John.

John Jantsch (21:28.206)

All right. Awesome. Well, thank you all for tuning in to another episode of the Duct Tape Marketing Podcast. And this is where I guess I’m supposed to say, hopefully we’ll see you one of these days out there on the road.

Sara Nay (21:42.109)

Thanks everyone.

 

 

The Framework That Transformed My Business (And Can Transform Yours Too)

The Framework That Transformed My Business (And Can Transform Yours Too) written by John Jantsch read more at Duct Tape Marketing

The Duct Tape Marketing Podcast with Nick Sonnenberg

In this episode of the Duct Tape Marketing Podcast, I interviewed Nick Sonnenberg, founder of Leverage, a leading operational efficiency consultancy, and author of the bestselling book Come Up for Air. Nick is an expert in business efficiency, team productivity, and workplace systems. His CPR framework has transformed the way businesses operate by addressing common bottlenecks in communication, planning, and resources.

During our conversation, Nick shared his personal journey of overcoming chaos in his business, where rapid growth led to inefficiency and burnout. He explained how the CPR framework—focusing on Communication, Planning, and Resources—helps organizations streamline workflows, improve team collaboration, and maximize time management. By implementing this approach, businesses can achieve operational efficiency, reduce stress, and create sustainable systems that support long-term success.

Nick Sonnenberg’s CPR framework is a game-changer for business owners looking to improve team productivity, streamline workflows, and create a stress-free operational environment. Whether you’re an overwhelmed entrepreneur or a growing organization, adopting this framework can transform how you work and set you up for long-term success.

Key Takeaways:

  • The CPR Framework
    • Communication: Streamline internal communication by consolidating tools and reducing unnecessary back-and-forth. For example, task-related discussions should live in project management tools, not Slack or email.
    • Planning: Centralize task and project management in tools like Asana or Monday.com. This ensures everyone knows what needs to be done, by whom, and when.
    • Resources: Create a knowledge base or wiki where team members can self-serve answers to routine questions, reducing disruptions and improving efficiency.
  • Prioritize Return on Time (ROT)
    • Focus on tasks that yield the highest time savings for the least investment. This approach ensures that efforts are directed toward impactful improvements in business workflows and team productivity.
  • Systemize Early to Scale Effectively
    • Even solopreneurs should start implementing systems early to prepare for growth. Small, incremental changes to streamline processes can prevent chaos as the business scales.
  • The Importance of Documentation
    • Use tools like Loom to record processes and create step-by-step guides. Documenting workflows not only helps current employees but also reduces risks when onboarding new team members or transitioning roles.
  • Long-Term vs. Short-Term Thinking
    • Businesses focused on long-term efficiency see greater success than those chasing quick wins. Investing in operational efficiency and business systems now creates a stress-free and scalable environment in the future.

Chapters:

  • [00:09] Introducing Nick Sonnenberg
  • [00:44] How Nick Stopped Drowning in Work
  • [06:25] Prioritizing Where to Start
  • [07:46] Focusing on What Matters
  • [10:08] Investing in Implementing Change
  • [11:34] Solving Operational Efficiency Holistically
  • [12:48] Best Practices of CPR (Communication, Planning, and Resources)
  • [16:24] What Size Business is CPR for?
  • [18:14] Find Out More About Nick and His Work

More About Duncan Wardle: 

This episode of the Duct Tape Marketing Podcast is brought to you by

Want to elevate your marketing game? AdCritter pairs Connected TV ads with precise digital retargeting to drive real results. Discover how their full-funnel strategy can help your business grow smarter. Let them know Duct Tape Marketing sent you, and you’ll get a dollar-for-dollar match on your first campaign! Learn more at adcritter.com.

Why Your Focus Groups Are Failing and What to Do Instead

Why Your Focus Groups Are Failing and What to Do Instead written by John Jantsch read more at Duct Tape Marketing

The Duct Tape Marketing Podcast with Jacqueline Lieberman

In this episode of the Duct Tape Marketing Podcast, I interviewed Jacqueline Lieberman, founder of Brand Crudo and creator of the Anti-Focus Group method. Jacqueline is a brand strategist who works with global giants like Google, Unilever, and Lexus to uncover raw truths and develop innovative brand strategies.

Jacqueline shared how traditional focus groups often fail to provide actionable customer insights and why a new approach is essential for B2B marketing success. She introduced the concept of the Anti-Focus Group, a unique method that replaces sterile conference rooms with VIP dinners to unlock authentic customer feedback, emotional triggers, and deeper connections. This revolutionary approach delivers valuable insights that drive impactful brand messaging, marketing solutions, and business strategies.

Jacqueline Lieberman’s Anti-Focus Group revolutionizes the way brands approach customer insights, brand strategy, and marketing innovation. By moving beyond traditional focus groups and leveraging intimate, VIP settings, businesses can unlock deeper emotional triggers, craft more impactful messaging, and elevate their B2B marketing efforts. If you’re ready to transform your approach to customer research and brand development, the Anti-Focus Group method offers a fresh, effective solution.

 

Key Takeaways:

  • Why Traditional Focus Groups Fail
    Traditional focus groups often take place in uninspiring environments, like conference rooms or Zoom panels, where participants feel detached or distracted. These settings fail to uncover the emotional triggers and raw truths needed for meaningful brand strategy.
  • The Power of Anti-Focus Groups
    Jacqueline’s Anti-Focus Group method uses curated VIP dinners to create a comfortable, engaging atmosphere. By fostering authentic conversations, this approach uncovers actionable customer insights and builds deeper connections.
  • Emotional Triggers and Customer Feedback
    Emotional triggers and customer mindsets are critical to effective marketing. The Anti-Focus Group method helps brands identify these elements, enabling them to craft brand messaging that resonates deeply with their target audience.
  • B2B Marketing Innovation
    In B2B settings, understanding executive feedback is key. The Anti-Focus Group method helps businesses gather these insights while also enhancing brand perception through high-quality, exclusive experiences.
  • Rapid and Actionable Insights
    Unlike traditional marketing research methods, Anti-Focus Groups provide a quick turnaround. Insights are delivered within 10 days, allowing brands to act swiftly and confidently on new strategies.

Chapters:

  • [00:09] Introducing Jacqueline Lieberman
  • [01:10] Anti-Focus Group Dinners: A New Approach to B2B Research
  • [05:17] Leveraging Dinner Events for Authentic Customer Feedback
  • [09:41] Impact of VIP Dinners
  • [12:41] Client Feedback of Anti-Focus Group Dinners
  • [14:38] Logistics and Strategy for B2B Client
  • [16:06] Scaling the Impact of Group Dinners

More About Jacqueline Lieberman: 

  • Check out Jacqueline Lieberman’s Website
  • Connect with Jacqueline Lieberman on LinkedIn

John Jantsch (00:01.282)

Hello and welcome to another episode of the Duct Tape Marketing Podcast. This is John Jantsch and my guest today is Jacqueline Lieberman. She’s former chief strategy officer at Story Worldwide, a master of narrative-based marketing, blending human insights with brand truths for giants like Unilever, Google, and Lexus. She’s now the founder of brand Crudo, which she created the DNA method to help &A executives and CMOs differentiate their brands by leveraging raw

truths that can’t be copied. Frustrated by the stale research methods, she also launched the Anti-Focus Group, exclusive dinners that deliver actionable insights from hard to reach audiences while doubling as premium brand experiences. So Jacqueline, welcome to the show.

Jacqueline Lieberman (00:49.624)

Thank you, john. feel like that’s the podcast. did such a great job with the intro. We’re done.

John Jantsch (00:52.452)

Well, I just read what you gave me to tell you the truth. So I take no credit credit for other than being able to read, which Mrs. Morrison in first grade made sure of.

Jacqueline Lieberman (00:57.262)

you

Jacqueline Lieberman (01:03.16)

There we go.

John Jantsch (01:04.228)

All right, so let’s define like what’s an anti-focus group dinner look like.

Jacqueline Lieberman (01:09.422)

sure. Yeah, well, let’s see, as the name suggests, it is the opposite of what a traditional focus group is. And because I am a believer that setting really matters. So when you think about traditional focus groups, they basically take two paths. The traditional route is that you think of this, you know, conference room, a stale conference room with a

what feels like this double glass, you know, one sided mirror that’s there that makes you feel like you’re in like an FBI interrogation room, you know, being detained for some reason. And then you have a moderator who nine times out of 10 really just looked at, you know, what they’re supposed to be talking about. And they don’t really have a lot of skin in the game as to like what to do with the information. So there’s that.

And then the, you know, with the advent of zoom and online panels. So now a lot of really where it’s gone is that you’re looking at a screen with a bunch of boxes that people are doing all day long anyway. And of course people are multitasking while they’re supposedly answering your questions and paying attention. So that’s made the whole feedback loop even worse in my opinion, you know? So yeah.

John Jantsch (02:31.564)

Yeah, yeah, yeah. So, no, I was just going to say, so, you’ve talked about all the limitations of those, but I mean, are, the real limitation that we’re not getting very much that’s actionable out of these? mean, is that why it’s broken?

Jacqueline Lieberman (02:33.998)

And so what I go ahead and you go.

Jacqueline Lieberman (02:51.254)

Yeah, I mean, so being 30 years on the receiving end of those reports, and that number is a real number three, zero. And, and I because I’m the one that’s supposed to do something with it as a brand strategist. This is supposed to be a gold mine of information by which I’m supposed to use as a foundation for brand strategy, audience messaging. And, you know, because of that,

John Jantsch (02:59.95)

Yeah.

Jacqueline Lieberman (03:21.068)

What I end up getting is I dig through a hundred pages of a poorly designed PowerPoint and the crux of it is really about it tells you exactly what was said in the room, which is helpful, but it doesn’t tell you why it was said. It doesn’t tell you really what the motivations are behind what some of the feedback was. And really what the anti-focus group dinners are about is

They’re designed to uncover key mindset and emotional triggers, right? So those are really the two foundational elements of marketing mindset and emotion. So that’s what this dinner setting is meant to unlock because immediately the professional armor comes off. As soon as they walk in the room, they’re like, this is like the best, this is the best part of my day right now. They’re treated like VIPs from the second they walk in.

And they’re sitting down to an amazing meal in an amazing setting. And I’m gently moderating the conversation. I’m not peppering them with a million questions, but it’s new course, new question, or new course, new sets of questions. And we talk about things like, how do you build trust with people? Who do you love to collaborate with and why?

Is there anything in your career that you haven’t done yet that you really want to do? Just so we can understand the more as people and not as targets is really what the feedback is.

John Jantsch (04:59.62)

So as I listen to those, it’s almost more like networking questions than research questions, right? It’s something you might typically want to uncover in a healthy networking conversation. But let’s back up a little bit. So I’m assuming, or maybe I’m wrong, but are these mostly, if not exclusively, B2B settings? OK. OK.

Jacqueline Lieberman (05:10.712)

Sure.

Jacqueline Lieberman (05:17.794)

Yeah, they seem to work for b2b, you know, so, you know, it’s not about, you know, let’s look at the latest box of Cheerios and determine what the creative is. It’s, it’s really more about business to business products and services.

John Jantsch (05:26.733)

Yeah, okay.

John Jantsch (05:34.116)

So I’m a customer or maybe a targeted customer. get invited to this. Am I told I’m going to dinner and it’s going to be a research? do you sometimes get a little, because it’s unique, do you sometimes get a little, wait a minute, what?

Jacqueline Lieberman (05:42.402)

Yes.

Jacqueline Lieberman (05:48.45)

Well, we get mostly the only wait a minute what is when we do disclose that they will be wearing microphones, because this is research, you know, so this is, you know, when I call it, it’s the most productive dinner you’ll ever sponsor all year, you know, it’s like you have b2b dinners all the time and networking, right and golf outings and all of this stuff. But but when people walk in,

John Jantsch (05:56.676)

Yeah.

John Jantsch (06:04.536)

Yeah, yeah.

Right.

Jacqueline Lieberman (06:14.574)

They we let them know in the invitation before they even respond that they will be mic’d up that this is for research and just like research in a focus group they do get compensated for their time. So we want them to feel that their time spent was immensely valuable in every way.

John Jantsch (06:36.42)

So I’m sure people forget about the microphones pretty quickly in, I’m imagining like, okay, I can’t burp, right? So, all right, so then you get, I assume the microphone is because you’re recording, right? So you get all of this recordings. How do you make sense out of them that in a way that you can actually address the objectives of the sponsor?

Jacqueline Lieberman (06:43.502)

We haven’t run into that.

Jacqueline Lieberman (07:02.464)

Yes. Well, before I answer that directly, I will address the so the mindset questions that I was saying before, we do have dinners where it is a mix, it really depends on the goal of the dinner. some goals of the dinner are to really understand their ideal customer way better in terms of their mindset and emotional triggers. So that could be the beginning of the dinner, the second half of the dinner could be very much of a brass tacks look,

John Jantsch (07:10.627)

Yeah, yeah.

John Jantsch (07:17.188)

Hmm.

Jacqueline Lieberman (07:30.246)

we would like you to respond to this messaging or this concept board. And I hand it I hand it out over dinner and say, you know, once we’re done, or we’re looking at dessert, and we say, Okay, what do you think about this particular concept or this tagline? So we can get to brass tacks and cover that for sure. But we recommend that it’s definitely going to be a balance of both mindset as well as the brass tacks to make it really worth the sponsoring companies while

John Jantsch (07:33.86)

Mm-hmm.

John Jantsch (08:00.258)

You know, I’ve always contended for years that, you know, one of the best things a company can do is bring their customers together so that they can, hey, you know, I’ve had this problem. They solved that problem for me too. So there’s networking, there’s referrals that go on. It’s people feel like champions now because you’ve treated them to dinner. Is there a little bit of a combination of, hey, we’re like treating you special and getting research from you?

Jacqueline Lieberman (08:07.266)

Yeah.

Jacqueline Lieberman (08:27.086)

for sure. Yeah, for sure. mean, and making them feel valued is part of where the authentic feedback comes in, you know, because when, you know, like I said, when that armor kind of comes down immediately, when you make this comfortable setting and you’re breaking bread with people and introducing yourself and all of a sudden, you’ll get a very different piece of feedback if you ask the same question in a zoom panel or in a conference room.

know, you just do and and that’s the the beauty of it. And and with your question before about you know, how do I weed through three hours of transcript but you know, I’ve been interviewing stakeholders my entire career, it’s part of my process for brand strategy, right? So so before I even, you know, put pen to paper on a brand foundation work, I

ask and say give me the 1015 people at your company who I should be talking to. So so I’ve been doing you know, trying to pull out the nuggets of what people say, you know, my whole career and this is really no different.

John Jantsch (09:37.944)

Yeah. Well, and I will say maybe you’ll disagree with it, but this idea, but, your, strategist brain creates the questions in the conversation, but I do think some of the new tools that we have AI tools, are very good at analysis if given the right data, right? Yeah.

Jacqueline Lieberman (09:50.446)

Mm-hmm.

Jacqueline Lieberman (09:54.938)

sure. Yeah, absolutely. I mean, it helps with calling down transcriptions and you know, maybe generating some themes but you know, I’m I’m the only one that has my client in the back of my brain to understand really what they’re looking for. So, that’s what I’m looking at when I look through those raw transcripts.

John Jantsch (10:07.82)

Yeah, that’s right.

John Jantsch (10:14.98)

So do you have an example maybe of a campaign or maybe you can’t name names but maybe talk a little bit about the impact of one of these dinners?

Jacqueline Lieberman (10:24.216)

Sure, yeah, I can’t name names or disclose, but we’ve had dinners where it was first, it’s like, okay, we need to really know our customers better because the current personas that we have just tell me the pain points of why they hate my technology, for instance. And I already knew that. can we really understand who they are as people? So that was dinner number one. Then we went back to work.

and said, okay, so this is the feedback from dinner number one, we worked on brand strategy and positioning. So we worked on actual messaging for campaigns and for websites, like for homepages, product descriptions, things like that. And it was a piece of technology for a platform. And, and then so dinner number two was very specific around, what do you think about what this company is saying and how they’re talking about their technology?

And that now that particular dinner informed what ended up on the website and what is in campaign development right now. And, you know, so CMOs are, you know, it’s a way to really kind of keep a quarterly pulse on, know, how their customers are evolving. Also how, you know, especially if it’s a B2B technology company.

John Jantsch (11:41.538)

Mm-hmm.

Jacqueline Lieberman (11:49.388)

You have a product roadmap, you’re constantly putting out new technology. So that’s always evolving. So, you know, they’re using it as these quarterly check-ins to understand if they’re on the right track.

John Jantsch (12:01.633)

Do you see this approach being something that has specific uses or do you think this is just going to reshape the way brands do research, period?

Jacqueline Lieberman (12:11.592)

mean, honestly, it’s, I mean, there’s nothing wrong with starting if brands are doing surveys, you know, things like that. I think there’s always a use for surveys because it casts out a wide net. And surveys will always be there for that reason is to get a beat on, you know, what the mass market or what your mass consumer is saying if we want to send it out to a couple of hundred people. Now, when you really start to

Any qualitative is usually second after that survey is like, okay, here are the general themes that we saw that people are saying and what they care about. Let’s dig in deeper. And usually that’s where, you know, focus groups and online panels come in. But, you know, as I said before, when we’re talking about really understanding, say, executive level insights, C-suite insights, they’re not going to focus groups. They’re not joining.

online panels, and maybe they’ll be doing a survey maybe. So this is the way to really understand what that B2B executive is really caring about and what motivates them.

John Jantsch (13:22.092)

Have you heard from clients that have done, I don’t know, let’s call it traditional as opposed to anti-focus group. Have you heard from some that say, wow, this is different or what’s been the feedback?

Jacqueline Lieberman (13:34.97)

yeah. I mean, I can’t so the feedback from clients and I’ll talk about the guests in a minute. but what clients are really loving is the fact that there there is this brand halo effect that happens. That’s that intangible effect of when people are leaving on a high. So even if they didn’t know the sponsoring brand coming in, you know, we disclose who the sponsoring company is. But even if they weren’t familiar with it at first, say,

John Jantsch (13:41.284)

Mm-hmm.

Jacqueline Lieberman (14:04.822)

Now they’re leaving the room, understanding them better, leaving on a high, networking and exchanging numbers with other guests. So it became like this peer to peer exchange dinner by default. you can’t beat getting a beautifully designed 15 to 20 page chock full of actionable insights where we go, here’s the main insight.

Here’s the main implication and here’s the very specific marketing opportunity. You get that within 10 days, not a month, not six weeks, not anything that you need like, well, can we look at this or that? Can you cut the data this way? It’s 10 days, they get exactly what they need to act on. And that’s what they’ve been loving.

John Jantsch (14:51.812)

So I heard you say that they may not know the brand. these are not customers. I just made an assumption that they’re interviewing customers or having customers at these.

Jacqueline Lieberman (14:59.648)

It’s a little it’s been both. So some it’s been let’s invite our existing pool of customers. And then there’s been you know what, we need to just recruit our existing profile and of people who may or may not know us, but we’re going to invite them to dinner anyway. So and you know, there’s a lot of gold in inviting those types of guests as well.

John Jantsch (15:22.99)

So there are some logistics, right? They have to be in the room. So do you, know, lot of B2B brands, their clients might be all over the country, all over the world. So does that add a layer of logistics and cost, I assume, right? Yeah.

Jacqueline Lieberman (15:26.094)

Correct.

Jacqueline Lieberman (15:33.368)

Yes.

Jacqueline Lieberman (15:38.072)

For sure. Yeah. I mean, I think really what we do is we start with the customer, the sponsoring company. Everybody has a sales, Jen demand, Jen lead list. So everybody has warm leads, hot leads. We start there and say, okay, who, who are they? Can we, can we get them into in a specific geo? And then once we get the geography down, then we pick the, the 20 that really will.

move the needle for the sponsoring company. then, you know, the, take care of all the logistics from there, which is as soon as I have those 15 to 20 people, then we start the outreach and, and I have to say the, you know, the venue is also very important because again, if we want people to come, we want them to be excited about it, that it’s time well spent. it’s

it’s in a venue that either they’ve heard about been there before or someplace that they’ve always wanted to go and just haven’t been. So the venue is definitely a draw. And that’s why, you know, we really insist on keeping the quality very high, because we want it to be, you know, really well worth their time, you know, when when they enter. So, yeah.

John Jantsch (16:56.388)

Is this something in your mind that you could write a book about, that you could teach, that you could certify other people to do, or do you have any plans to scale it beyond your work?

Jacqueline Lieberman (17:07.266)

Yeah, I mean, I’ve thought about, you know, I thought about a book at least, in thinking about just kind of the magic that happens when you break bread with people around the table and and what you kind of learn from that because guests come in as complete strangers and then they leave almost as friends. I mean, they’re hugging me at the end, you know, taking selfies with a group selfies of all of us, they’re exchanging information.

John Jantsch (17:32.004)

Right.

Jacqueline Lieberman (17:36.174)

We connect on LinkedIn and every single person who on LinkedIn has commented on any of my posts, if they were a guest, they say, I mean, here’s the other thing. They haven’t just commented like one sentence like, that was great. Paragraphs, I’m getting paragraphs of comments saying this was unlike anything I’ve ever experienced. You know, it was a way that…

John Jantsch (17:55.204)

video.

Jacqueline Lieberman (18:02.274)

we opened up I keep in touch with the people around the table that I met that night now on a consistent basis. So it’s it’s a really nice ripple effect that happens, you know, after that particular dinner, which is which feels great. You know? Yeah.

John Jantsch (18:17.228)

Yeah, absolutely. Well, Jacqueline, I appreciate you taking a moment to stop by and tell us a little bit about what you’re working on. Is there any place you’d invite people to find out more about your work or certainly about

Jacqueline Lieberman (18:30.016)

Yeah, absolutely. They can just go to brand crudo dot com and there’s an anti focus group tab right there and they can find out more info.

John Jantsch (18:40.132)

I’m going show my ignorance here and I’m sure you told me the last time you were on the show, what’s the significance of the word of the yeah, yeah, yeah.

Jacqueline Lieberman (18:46.03)

brand crudo. So part of the DNA method of what I uncover for brands to help out maneuver their competition is that I believe that every brand has a raw truth, you know, and that’s part of their DNA. So, so that’s where crudo came from. And, that’s what I helped them uncover and tell to the world through strategy.

John Jantsch (18:59.986)

John Jantsch (19:10.486)

Awesome. again, appreciate you taking a few moments to stop by and hopefully we’ll run into you one of these days out there on the road.

Jacqueline Lieberman (19:17.046)

awesome. Thank you, john. Thank you so much for having me. Bye bye.

John Jantsch (19:19.492)

You bet.

 

 

Clone of Weekend Favs January 18th

Clone of Weekend Favs January 18th written by Jordan E read more at Duct Tape Marketing

My weekend blog post routine includes posting links to a handful of tools or great content I ran across during the week.

I don’t go into depth about the finds, but I encourage you to check them out if they sound interesting. The photo in the post is a favorite for the week from an online source or one I took on the road.

  • NotebookLM: AI-powered tool by Google for summarizing and generating insights from notes.
  • Mem: Smart workspace that organizes and connects ideas automatically.
  • Obsidian: Markdown-based app for creating a personal knowledge graph.

These are my weekend favs; I would love to hear about some of yours – Connect with me on Linkedin!

If you want to check out more Weekend Favs you can find them here.

How Strategic Planning Can Help You Crush Your Goals in 2025

How Strategic Planning Can Help You Crush Your Goals in 2025 written by John Jantsch read more at Duct Tape Marketing

Strategic planning is one of those things that’s easy to push off because, let’s face it, running a business keeps you busy. But here’s the deal: if you don’t have a clear plan, it’s way harder to hit your goals. You’ll just be spinning your wheels instead of moving forward.

At Duct Tape Marketing, we’ve been tweaking our strategic planning process for years, and it’s been a game-changer. Since we started using this approach, we’ve grown our revenue by over 20% every year

If you’re ready to map out your best year yet, let’s take a look at how we do it.

What Is Strategic Planning, Really?

Strategic planning is just a fancy way of saying you’re making a plan to reach your goals and figuring out how to take action. It’s about thinking big (one-year and three-year goals) and then breaking it down into smaller, manageable chunks you can focus on every quarter.

A lot of people skip strategic planning because they feel too busy, or they don’t follow through after they make the plan. That’s why having a simple system makes all the difference.

Our Go-To Framework for Strategic Planning

At Duct Tape Marketing, we mix mindset, goal-setting, and action steps into a process that actually works. Here’s how:

1. Get Clear on What Matters to You

Before you dive into business goals, take a minute to think about your personal values. What drives you? What matters most? When you’re clear on this, it’s way easier to stay motivated and make decisions that align with what you care about.

Try This:

Grab a notebook (or our handy spreadsheet) and brainstorm what’s important to you. Is it work-life balance? Making an impact? Financial security? Once you have your list, rank your top 10. These are your guideposts for staying focused and grounded as you plan.

2. Lay the Foundation for Your Business

Your business needs a strong foundation. This means knowing your purpose, values, what makes you unique, and who your ideal customers are. This step sets the stage for everything else you’ll do—from marketing to operations.

Ask Yourself:

  • Why does my business exist? What’s the deeper purpose?

  • What values define how we operate and interact with clients?

  • How are we different from competitors in our space?

  • Who are we trying to help? What do they need from us?

Taking the time to answer these questions creates clarity and ensures every decision you make aligns with your bigger picture.

3. Write Down Your Goals

If you don’t write it down, it’s not a real goal—it’s just a wish. Studies show that people who write their goals are way more likely to achieve them. For your business, focus on revenue and profit targets for the next year and three years.

SMARTER Goals:

We use a twist on the classic SMART goals. Our SMARTER goals are:

  • Specific: Clear and actionable.

  • Measurable: Define success with numbers.

  • Achievable: Set a stretch goal, but keep it realistic.

  • Relevant: Align with your overall strategy.

  • Time-Based: Set a deadline.

  • Empowering: Goals should inspire you and your team.

  • Reflective: Make sure they align with your values and purpose.

4. Figure Out Your “Why”

This one’s huge. Why do your goals matter? When things get tough (and they will), your “why” is what keeps you going and reminds you why you started in the first place.

Example:

“I want to grow revenue by 20% because it will let me provide stability for my family, expand my team, and give back to my community.”

A strong “why” is like a north star—it keeps you motivated and focused no matter what challenges come your way.

5. Plan Quarterly Priorities

Breaking your big goals into quarterly priorities makes them way less overwhelming. Plus, it gives you a chance to adjust as things change, whether that’s in your business or the market.

What to Do:

  • Set a specific revenue target for the quarter.

  • Identify three main priorities to focus on.

  • Break each priority into smaller projects with clear deadlines and team assignments.

By tackling one quarter at a time, you’ll feel a sense of accomplishment and build momentum towards your bigger goals.

6. Schedule Time for Your Plan

All the planning in the world won’t help if you don’t take action. Block time on your calendar to work on your priorities—and treat it like an unbreakable meeting.

Pro Tip:

Experiment with what works for you. Maybe you dedicate Mondays to strategy or block out mornings for focused work. The key is sticking to your schedule and showing up for yourself just like you would for a client or team meeting.

pencil on opened notebook

How AI Can Make Planning Easier

AI tools like ChatGPT can help you work smarter and make strategic planning more effective. Here’s how:

  • Analyze your data for trends, opportunities, and patterns.

  • Compare your priorities to long-term goals to ensure alignment.

  • Use AI to streamline repetitive tasks, freeing up time for high-level thinking and strategy.

AI isn’t just a tool—it’s like having a data analyst and assistant by your side, helping you make better decisions faster.

Tying It All Back to Marketing

Strategic planning isn’t just for operations—it’s the foundation for effective marketing too. At Duct Tape Marketing, we use a Marketing Strategy Pyramid that builds on your business strategy. Once you know where you’re headed, you can create a marketing plan that supports your goals and drives real results.

Let’s Get Started

Ready to make a plan for 2025? Make a copy and download our strategic planning spreadsheet and start mapping out your goals. If you’re feeling stuck or want help taking your plan to the next level, let’s chat. We’re passionate about helping businesses create strategies that actually work.

Stop Killing Ideas! Use “Yes, And” Instead of “No, Because”

Stop Killing Ideas! Use “Yes, And” Instead of “No, Because” written by John Jantsch read more at Duct Tape Marketing

The Duct Tape Marketing Podcast with Duncan Wardle

In this episode of the Duct Tape Marketing Podcast, I interviewed Duncan Wardle, former Head of Innovation and Creativity at Disney, who shared his strategies for embedding innovation and creativity into organizational culture. Duncan has spent decades fostering innovation in some of the world’s most iconic brands, including Disney Imagineering, Pixar, and Lucasfilm. His fresh approach emphasizes breaking free from traditional thinking, fostering playful leadership, and reframing challenges to create breakthrough solutions.

During our conversation, Duncan highlighted the power of replacing the dismissive “No, because” mindset with the collaborative “Yes, and” approach. This simple shift not only encourages creative thinking but also transforms individual ideas into collective solutions that are more likely to succeed. By fostering a culture of playful leadership, embedding innovation into the DNA of teams, and solving consumer pain points with reframing strategies, leaders can drive sustainable growth and cultivate organizational creativity.

Key Takeaways:

  • Adopt the “Yes, And” Mindset
    Replace “No, because” with “Yes, and” to foster collaborative brainstorming and build on ideas instead of shutting them down.
  • Reframe Challenges for Better Solutions
    Instead of asking, “How can we make more money?” reframe questions to solve consumer pain points, like Disney did with their Magic Band innovation.
  • Leverage Playfulness to Unlock Creativity
    Incorporate playful leadership techniques, such as short energizers and humor, to shift teams into a creative and problem-solving mindset.
  • Embed Innovation into Your Culture
    Avoid isolating creativity in specific teams—empower all employees to think innovatively as part of their roles.
  • Look Outside Your Industry for Inspiration
    Borrow ideas and technologies from other industries to inspire creative thinking and problem-solving.
  • Reclaim Imagination and Creativity
    Break free from the constraints of traditional education and encourage curiosity, intuition, and imagination in your workplace.

Chapters:

  • [00:09] Introduction to Duncan Wardle
  • [01:00] Defining Innovation and Embedding a Culture of Creativity
  • [03:12] Embracing Innate Creativity
  • [04:48] The Future of Employability
  • [09:38] Collaborative Brainstorming Exercise
  • [12:43] Unlocking Creativity through Playfulness and Collaboration
  • [17:01] River of Thinking and Innovation

More About Duncan Wardle: 

This episode of the Duct Tape Marketing Podcast is brought to you by

Want to elevate your marketing game? AdCritter pairs Connected TV ads with precise digital retargeting to drive real results. Discover how their full-funnel strategy can help your business grow smarter. Let them know Duct Tape Marketing sent you, and you’ll get a dollar-for-dollar match on your first campaign! Learn more at adcritter.com.

 

John Jantsch (00:01.89)

Hello and welcome to another episode of the Duct Tape Marketing Podcast. This is John Jantsch. My guest today is Duncan Wardle. He’s the former head of innovation and creativity at Disney. Duncan played a pivotal role in fostering innovation across Imagineering, Lucasfilm, Marvel, Pixar, and Disney parks, crafting enchanting new storylines and experiences. He’s also the author of a book we’re going to talk about today, The Imagination Emporium.

Creative recipes for innovation. So Duncan, welcome to the show.

Duncan (00:34.324)

Thank you, thanks very much for having me.

John Jantsch (00:36.074)

So one of my viewers, listeners, not viewers, won’t be able to know this, but one of my favorite characters is Goofy. You’ve got him right there behind you.

Duncan (00:46.794)

Yeah, so yes, these are hand-painted. It’s not an illustration. Yeah, they were created a few years ago now.

John Jantsch (00:55.106)

Very, very cool. So there was a book I read right when I was getting started, actually, that was very influential on me. was written by Peter Drucker and one of the comments in there was that he said that the only two things in business that matter are marketing and innovation. Everything else is a cost. I think a lot of people quote that and I’ve heard that phrase many times, but I’m wondering, like,

If we asked 10 people what innovation actually was at a company, I think we would get maybe 11 or 12 definitions. So how do you frame the idea of innovation? mean, it’s very large concept.

Duncan (01:32.57)

Yeah, crystal clear. Creativity is the ability to have an idea. We can all do that. We do it every day. Innovation is the ability to get it done. The challenge for most of us is the more experience, the more expertise we have, the more reasons we know why the new idea won’t work. So we constantly shoot it down. I call it our river of thinking. And it’s very fast and very wide and very allowing you and me to make quick and informed decisions. But in the last four years, we’ve seen global pandemics.

John Jantsch (01:39.394)

Yeah, yeah, yeah. Nice.

Duncan (01:58.762)

We’ve seen Generation Z entering the workplace but doesn’t want to work for corporate America. We’ve got artificial intelligence entering the marketplace. And what was the fourth one? There’s four of them. Global pandemic, Generation Z entering the workplace, artificial intelligence. Doesn’t matter. The world’s changed, right? And it’s changed irrevocably. We can’t go back to thinking the way we thought four years ago. And so, you know, Disney, I tried four models of innovation. Model number one.

I hired somebody who knew what they were doing. I said, make me look good. That was an agency. And to a certain extent, they did. They were never around for execution. And they certainly weren’t going to show me how they did what they did, or they were worried I wouldn’t hire them again. Model number two, we’re creating an innovation team. Duncan will be in charge. What could possibly go wrong? Well, outside of legal, who does legal work? Outside of marketing, who does marketing work? Nobody. So when you create an innovation team, you subliminally just told everybody else you’re off the hook.

We tried an accelerator program which created some level of access enabling us to partner with some young tech startups and bring some new technology to market. But we had failed in our overall goal, which was set by the CEO of Disney, was how might we embed a culture of innovation and creativity into everybody’s DNA. So I set out to create a toolkit that has three principles. It takes the BS out of innovation and makes it less intimidating to normal, hardworking people.

Make creativity tangible for those people who are uncomfortable with ambiguity and gray. Fun, more importantly, make the process fun. Give people tools they choose to use when you and I are not around.

John Jantsch (03:31.062)

All right, so and I’m sure you hear this all the time. I know you’ll have a great answer for this, but what do do in those organizations or individuals who we know there are lots of them, but say, I’m just not creative. Yeah.

Duncan (03:44.488)

Yeah, I disagree. I’m sorry. Look, let me ask you question. When you were a small boy, what was your favorite toy?

John Jantsch (03:54.094)

Probably a stick.

Duncan (03:55.594)

See what why because the stick was your lightsaber. That’s why it was your wand It was anything you wanted it to be and we were all born creative with an amazing image when you were given a gift for a holiday and it came in an enormous box and it took you ages to take the toy out of the box what do you spend the rest of week playing with Yeah, the box right it was your rocket it was your force it was your cart It was anything you wanted to be till you went to the number one killer of creativity Education and the first thing your first grade teacher told you to do was don’t forget to color in between the lines

John Jantsch (04:10.798)

The fort.

John Jantsch (04:20.044)

Right.

Duncan (04:24.586)

Small children, they’re very curious. ask why, why, why, why, why again? Because they’re seeking the core consumer truth. They’re after the insight for innovation. If I were to survey 5,000 people and ask them why they go to Disney on holiday, the number one response I’ll get is we go for the new attractions. But that’s not strictly true, is it? So if I were to rely just on my data, I’d go spend $250 million on a capital investment strategy. But if I pause for a moment and I act childlike, not childish, and say, well, why do you go for the new attractions? Well, now I like the classics. Why do you like the classics? Well, I like it’s a small world.

Why do you like it? a small world. Why remember music? God, no, not the music. Why the music? Where’s my mum’s favourite ride we used to go every summer? Why is that important to you 20 years later? I’ll take my daughter now. Boom. There’s your insight for innovation. Call consumer truth. It’s got nothing to do with the capital investment strategy and everything to do with that person’s personal memory and nostalgia. But then we go to the number one killer of curiosity, education. And the next thing we’re taught to do is to stop asking why, because there’s only one right answer. Here comes artificial intelligence, right?

You think we used to laugh at the blue collar workers? Well, guess what? They’ll be laughing at the white collar workers now. But I’ve been working with Google on their DeepMind project, which is their AI project. And I asked the lead engineer what I said, how the hell am I going to compete with this? You know, what will be the most employable skill sets the next five to 10 years? And she said, that’s easy. The ones that will be the hardest for her to program into AI. I said, well, what are those? says, the ones with which you were born, imagination, creativity, curiosity, empathy, and intuition. But they’re drummed out of us by the time we’re 18.

That’s the challenge.

John Jantsch (05:51.81)

Yeah, Of course, having some handy set of plumbing skills will become very necessary too though, It is.

Duncan (06:00.52)

No seriously hands-on workers absolutely fine. look I set out here’s why people say why do you write a book. Let me ask you quite an honest question here. When you see a business book in an office physically where is the book?

John Jantsch (06:15.022)

laying on a desk.

Duncan (06:16.616)

Yeah, there you go. it’s on the coffee table. It’s on the bookshelf. I’m going to get to it tomorrow, but my boss needs this now, so I actually never read it. I have good intentions to read it, but I don’t. So I thought, OK, how do I make it more accessible to people who’ve got other things to do? I thought, what nonfiction book have I ever read where I could read one page today and know exactly what I was going to do and not worry about the rest of the book today? My mum’s cookbook. You want shepherd’s pie? You got to pay 67. So the contents page is designed for busy people. It says, have you ever been to a brainstorm where nothing ever happened?

Go to page 67. Don’t know how to find insights for innovation? Go to page 42. Work in a heavily regulated industry? Go to page 67. So it’s designed to be very accessible, but it’s also designed to appeal to what I call the three sensory learning styles. So let me ask you a question. May I ask you to close your eyes for just a moment?

How many days are there in September? I would ask you to keep your eyes closed and tell me how you knew, how you remembered, how you learned or what you could see with your eyes closed right now. Bingo, you can open your eyes. 30 % of the people will recite the rhyme. 30 days has September, blah, blah. No, it’s true. And so they just told me they learn by listening. They probably read a lot. It’s an auditory style. How do I know that? Because they were six when they learned it. How did they remember it? Because they heard it. Another 30%.

John Jantsch (07:07.502)

30.

John Jantsch (07:15.626)

see a calendar.

John Jantsch (07:21.856)

Yeah, yeah.

Duncan (07:33.502)

Put the knuckles together and start counting the knuckles. January, February, March, April, May, June, June. Those are kinesthetic learners. By the way, John, you were taught both, but you don’t remember either because that’s not your preferred learning style. You’re the majority of the audience. You learn by seeing. You represent 40 percent of the audience. So I thought, OK, how do I create a book that’s not a book? I want it to be a toolkit. I want it to be fun, but I want it to be purposeful. I want it to appeal to all three learning styles. So it has QR codes embedded with each chapter with Spotify playlists for auditory learners.

It has animated videos in each chapter where Duncan is now an animated character. I pop out of the book with a bunch of other characters I’ve created for the visual learners and teach you how to use the tools and for our kinesthetic learners starting, I think today, but maybe in a couple of days from now, the QR code on the back of the book will actually take you directly to the very first ever fully integrated artificial intelligence book.

Why? Because I’ve never done it before. That’s why. So you will be able to ask the book questions and through chat. It’ll answer you through WhatsApp. So you might say, how do I use the tool on page 67? And it’ll answer you. But you could also say, how do I use the tool on page 67 to develop a marketing campaign that’s more of a mercy to experience for my brand? And the book will answer you.

John Jantsch (08:50.158)

Who published this book?

Duncan (08:52.266)

You know what, Amplify

John Jantsch (08:54.798)

So I’ve written several books with major publishers and I’m envisioning the meeting where you described what this book was going to be like.

Duncan (09:04.2)

I kept telling the publisher, we thought, he said it’s a book. I said, hell no, it’s not. It’s a toolkit. By the way, I want to give it away for free. Needless to say, the publisher had other ideas. I still want to give it away for students because we are killing the most employable skill sets in the next decade.

John Jantsch (09:19.502)

Yeah. So if you’re going to work with an organization that, and again, I don’t know if that’s a service you offer consulting, but if you were going to work with an organization, I mean, what are some of the mindsets they would have, you would try to get them to change the habits you would get them to change that would really make this come to life?

Duncan (09:35.686)

Here’s the first one and this is particularly for leaders, right? Because again, the more experience we have, the more reasons we know why the new idea won’t work. So John, you and I have been tasked with coming up with an idea for a birthday party, for a Harry Potter birthday party. Are you familiar with Harry Potter?

John Jantsch (09:53.166)

I’m not a, yes, I’m familiar, but I’m not a junkie.

Duncan (09:59.378)

No, but have you seen a couple of films? OK, good. So I’m going to come at you with some ideas for a Harry Potter party. I’d like you to start each and every response with the following two words. No, because they’ll be the first two words you use and you’ll tell me why not. I was thinking of coming to your house, putting a sorting hat outside the front door, having all the good people get the Gryffindor party, but all the bad people get the Slytherin party.

John Jantsch (10:01.079)

I have.

John Jantsch (10:20.428)

No, because everybody just wants to play Quidditch.

Duncan (10:24.921)

right, I tell you what then, we’ll give everybody a broomstick and they can go running around the back garden looking like idiots and work the snitch to be acting on a drone.

John Jantsch (10:29.806)

No, because they can’t really fly.

Duncan (10:34.406)

Alright, fair point. I’ll tell you what then, let’s say that we’ll bring them all indoors and we’ll have a magic potions room where we can all drink something that turns us into something totally freaky.

John Jantsch (10:42.766)

no, because, there’s actually a giant animal in the back closet that would probably eat everyone.

Duncan (10:53.898)

Fair point. tell you what then, what if we just showed the movies? We’ll put them on your TV screen and we’ll serve butterbeer and No because, come on. So let me ask you question. When somebody’s constantly no becauseing you, how does that make you feel?

John Jantsch (11:00.14)

that’s perfect. No, because there might be somebody allergic to popcorn.

John Jantsch (11:13.432)

frustrated.

Duncan (11:14.364)

Okay, I would call it business as usual. Let me ask you a question. Do you think our idea was getting bigger as we were going or was it getting smaller? Which way was it headed?

John Jantsch (11:16.578)

Yeah.

John Jantsch (11:21.486)

It was, we were down to watching the movies. It was getting smaller.

Duncan (11:25.48)

Yeah, all right. Let’s start again. Are you familiar with Star Wars? OK, so I’m going to come at you with some Star Wars ideas. Unlike Harry Potter, where you started the response every single time with no, because this time I’d like you to start every single response with the words yes and and we’ll just build on it together. So I was thinking of coming to your house, getting into the kitchen, painting it black, turning it into the Death Star canteen and we could have a food and wine festival and half of the boo and tattoo.

John Jantsch (11:29.518)

Yes.

John Jantsch (11:50.632)

yeah, yes, and let’s add stormtroopers.

Duncan (11:53.462)

yes, and yeah, we can have a cosplay party. All the tall people could come as Darth Vader and all the little people would come dressed as Ewoks.

John Jantsch (11:55.993)

Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yes. And we’ve got to have Yoda, don’t we?

Duncan (12:03.121)

yes, and we can have the force. Everybody get a glow in the dark lightsaber full of their favorite alcoholic liquid.

John Jantsch (12:10.198)

Yes, and what about Darth Vader? Could he appear?

Duncan (12:14.362)

yes, and we could have Harrison Ford. We could bring back, yeah, or even the dead celebrities could come back via hologram and we could take them all on your corporate jet down to Disneyland to see the new galaxy’s edge.

John Jantsch (12:24.526)

Yes, and why not invite George Lucas?

Duncan (12:27.176)

Alright, so we’ll stop there. So a lot more laughter, a lot more energy. Most of us became Italian for the first time today, waving our arms. This time around, bigger or smaller.

John Jantsch (12:31.608)

Yeah.

John Jantsch (12:37.432)

Well, it kept getting much larger.

Duncan (12:39.434)

You can always take a big idea and value engineer it down. Pretty hard to turn a small one into a big one. Far more importantly, we work inside big organizations, we work inside small organizations, we have colleagues and constituents and clients to bring on board with our idea. By the time you and I just finished building the idea together, whose idea was it by the time we finished?

John Jantsch (12:58.145)

well was totally mine.

Duncan (12:59.53)

I would argue ours, John, thank you. So here’s the thing, two little magical words, yes and, have the power to turn a small idea into a big one really quickly. But far more importantly, have the power to transfer my idea, which never goes anywhere inside an organization, to our idea and accelerate its opportunity to get done. Just remind yourselves, I know you’re leaders, I know you’ve got responsibilities and quarterly results and deadlines. Just remind ourselves, we’re not green lighting this idea for execution today. We are merely green housing it together using yes.

If you take nothing away from listening to today’s podcast, don’t let the words know because be the first two words out of your mouth when somebody comes at you with a new idea. They have made genius two days from now, two weeks from now. You’ll never hear it. Your job as a leader is just that you’ll get to the know because but don’t start there. The other thing that I tried to teach is playfulness and I’ll tell you for why. Can I ask you to close your eyes? Where are you and what are you doing when you get your best ideas?

John Jantsch (13:47.405)

Yeah.

John Jantsch (13:59.438)

Definitely outside.

Duncan (14:01.768)

OK, so you can open your eyes. I’ve done this with up to 20,000 people. You’re here. Shower, bathroom, jogging, walking, driving, commuting, gym. Do you know how many people say at work? Nobody. Not one person ever writes down at work. Well, why not? Close your eyes again. Picture that last argument you were in. Bit of a shouting match. You’re angry at them. They’re angry at you. Now you turn to walk away from that argument. You’re 10, 20, 30 seconds away. You’re about a minute away from the argument and…

John Jantsch (14:12.142)

the

Duncan (14:30.026)

What just popped into your brain totally spontaneously the second you turned to walk away from that argument? What was it? Well, you should have said the killer one-liner, that one perfect, beautiful lie. You wish you’d choose to the argument, but you didn’t, did you? No, never did. Why not? Because when we’re in an argument, our brain is moving at a thousand miles an hour defending ourselves. When we’re at work, we’re doing emails and presentations and reports and we hear ourselves say, the number one barrier to innovation, I don’t have time to think. And when you say, don’t have time to think, you’re in the brain state science calls beta.

John Jantsch (14:34.702)

what I should have said.

Nope.

Duncan (14:58.57)

where the door between conscious and subconscious brain is firmly closed. When that door is closed, you only have access to your conscious brain. That is 13 % of the capacity of your brain. 87 % of the capacity of your brain is your subconscious brain. Every creative problem you’ve ever solved, every innovation you’ve seen is back here to serve as unrelated stimulus. But when the door is shut, you don’t have access to it. So how do I move you from there metaphorically and place you back in the shower where it is when you have your best ideas? You can still make an informed decision.

But still have a big idea that brain state is known as alpha. I call it amazing alpha. The best brain state for creativity at work. How do I get you there? By being playful. What do I do? I run an energizer. Well, what’s that? It’s a 60 second exercise. What am I doing? I’m making you laugh. Why am I making you laugh? Because the moment I hear laughter, I know that I’ve just opened the door between your conscious and subconscious brain. When we ask who are the most creative people you’ve ever met, everybody always says children. And I always hear people say, we don’t have the resources. You say,

Who are the most creative people? Children. how much money they got? none. Now, I don’t expect people to be playful every minute of every day. Life would be great fun, but we wouldn’t get much work done. I do expect you, particularly as leaders, to be playful at the right time.

John Jantsch (16:07.18)

Yeah, you know, I read something recently about this idea of why children, you know, are able to have just such rich imaginations and such creativity. and it, well, the person concluded that, that actually, you know, young children, particularly, are halfway in a fantasy world, you know, and, we sort of the school and everything sort of beats that out of them says, no, this is reality. But, but it’s an interesting thought that,

Duncan (16:16.778)

I haven’t gone to school yet.

John Jantsch (16:34.778)

They’re able to be so creative because they really live between reality and fantasy.

Duncan (16:39.922)

Yeah, very true. Very true. No, it’s true. Education is killing the most employable skill sets of the next decade. The future of education is gaming. Education will not exist as it exists today. Why? Because it deserves to die. Why? Because your children are learning the same thing I learned at school but I went in the 70s. That’s why.

John Jantsch (16:47.694)

Yeah.

John Jantsch (16:56.483)

Yeah. Yeah. Multiplication tables are not going to be really a necessary skill, are they? So I want to talk a little more about, you mentioned it briefly, but I think there’s a lot more to this idea of river of thinking. Can you kind of talk about that metaphor and how it both informs and gets in the way?

Duncan (17:12.38)

Yeah, we all got stuck in it. You know, I worked at Disney for 30 years and I was helping Lucas, Lucas Films, Marvel and Pixar have new ideas. But the challenge is when you’re talking to anybody who’s worked in one particular line of business for a long time is they become so entrenched in what I call their river of thinking. So let me explain how that or the danger of a river of thinking. You and I are going to go into business together and we’re going to open a car wash. Tell me if you were three or four essential ingredients we must have in our car wash.

John Jantsch (17:41.454)

customers, water, employees.

Duncan (17:42.718)

What else?

What else?

Employees, customers, employees and water. OK, you and I are actually, are venture capitalists. We’ve been invited to open a brand new franchise of auto spas. Who are a spa? Now close your eyes. What would you what have you seen in the spa? What would you like to see in your spa? What could we have in the spa?

John Jantsch (18:06.926)

Great music. Very, very comfortable, fancy chairs.

Duncan (18:08.714)

Okay, what else?

Duncan (18:13.94)

Okay.

Duncan (18:18.442)

What else have you seen? There we go. So you can open your eyes. I said car wash straight into your river of thinking, right? Water brushes, so vacuum dryer. I said auto spa, which is about the same product. We’ve got masseuses, we’ve got many pedis. So this tool is brilliant. Walt Disney created it. He said we will not have any customers in our park. We will only have guests. We will not have any employees. We’ll only have cast members. And with that simple re-expression of the relationship between the customer and the employees, the cast member, the guests.

John Jantsch (18:18.774)

Aromas aromas. Yeah

John Jantsch (18:25.32)

Yeah.

Duncan (18:47.514)

everybody got out of their river of thinking created this culture of hospitality. Our river of thinking is this, how might we make more money? How might we make our quarterly results? If we continue to ask that question, we’d put the gate price up at Walt Disney World by three percent, you’d have complained and we’d have made our quarterly results. You don’t get to iterate in a post pandemic world. You innovate or you die. So instead of asking the question we ask ourselves every day, because that’s our river of thinking, how might we make more money? We reversed the challenge and said,

How might we solve the biggest consumer pain point? Everybody knew what it was. It was called standing line. And I said, what if there were no lines? Didn’t know how to solve it at the time. And we looked outside of our industry for an insight for innovation. Most of the insights for innovation come from looking outside of your industry. It’s called Where Else? It’s in the book. And we noticed there was a very small pharmacy in Tokyo, Japan, using RFID technology to enable people not to stand in line. Welcome to the world of Disney’s Magic Band. Does it come in red or gray in the mail?

Of it does. Why? Because you’re like, right, the Star Wars edition. Does it come with matching merchandise? Of course it does. This is my room key today. I don’t check in or check out of a Disney Resort Hotel. It’s my theme park tickets, my reservations for my character meet and greets and my rides. Now it’s morphing towards the phone. I can pull for merchandise and have it sent to my hotel room or house, depending on how many times I touch it. I can order my food through my smartphone, walk into the restaurant when I want to walk in, sit at the table I want to sit at. The food comes fresh to me. Had we started by saying, how might we make more money? Yeah, we’d have made 3%.

but by reversing the challenge and asking how might we solve and getting out of our river of thinking, say, how might we solve the biggest consumer pain point? The average guest at Walt Disney World today has two hours free time they didn’t have six years ago each and every day. What does that result in? Record intent to recommend, record intent to return and record revenues. What do people do with their free time in Disney parks? They spend a bucket load of money.

John Jantsch (20:29.58)

Yeah. All right. Buy more stuff. Absolutely. Well, Duncan, this has been a fascinating interview. I’m not sure if you interviewed me or I interviewed you, but nonetheless, I think the listeners will be the better for it. I really appreciate you taking a moment to stop by. there someplace you’d invite people to find out more about your work and the imagination?

Duncan (20:40.906)

you

Duncan (20:54.228)

Well, they can normally find me in the Lammon Flag pub in Covent Garden, but if I’m not there, they could go to the imagination emporium dot com or Duncan Wardle.

John Jantsch (21:01.762)

Well, again, I appreciate you taking a moment to share and hopefully we’ll run into you one of these days out there on the road. Likewise.

Duncan (21:07.388)

Nice to meet you.

 

 

Why Two Weeks Notice Is Hurting Workplace Culture

Why Two Weeks Notice Is Hurting Workplace Culture written by John Jantsch read more at Duct Tape Marketing

The Duct Tape Marketing Podcast with Robert Glazer

In this episode of the Duct Tape Marketing Podcast, I interviewed Robert Glazer, founder of Acceleration Partners, a global partner marketing agency, and author of the bestselling book Rethinking Two Weeks Notice. Robert is an expert in workplace culture, employee retention, and leadership. His work challenges outdated corporate practices and offers fresh strategies for creating thriving workplace environments.

During our conversation, Robert shared powerful insights on why the traditional “two weeks’ notice” practice is no longer effective and how companies can replace it with the Open Transition Program. By fostering psychological safety, improving communication, and rethinking job exit strategies, businesses can enhance employee retention, protect workplace culture, and build long-term loyalty.

Robert Glazer’s fresh perspective on employee transitions offers actionable strategies for improving employee retention, workplace culture, and corporate reputation. By replacing outdated practices like the two weeks’ notice with the Open Transition Program, businesses can create a supportive, loyal, and high-performing work environment.

Key Takeaways:

  • Why Two Weeks’ Notice Is Outdated
    The traditional two weeks’ notice creates rushed transitions, strains relationships, and disrupts workplace culture. This outdated rule often leaves both employers and employees feeling dissatisfied and unsupported during career transitions.
  • The Open Transition Program: A Better Solution
    Robert introduced the Open Transition Program, a proactive approach that encourages open conversations about career transitions. By providing a structured and supportive process, employees can leave on better terms, ensuring smoother transitions for all parties.
  • Psychological Safety Is the Foundation of Loyalty
    Building psychological safety within the workplace allows employees to share their career aspirations and challenges without fear. This creates an environment of trust, where transitions can be managed with transparency and respect.
  • Strengthening Workplace Culture Through Better Transitions
    Employee transitions are a crucial but often overlooked aspect of workplace culture. A thoughtful approach to resignations and career changes demonstrates respect for employees and reinforces a culture of trust and collaboration.
  • The Long-Term Benefits of Positive Transitions
    Companies that implement better job exit strategies often see long-term benefits, including alumni referrals, Boomerang employees, and stronger client relationships. Treating employees well at the end of their tenure creates lifelong advocates for the brand.
  • Replacing Resentment with Respect
    Traditional resignation practices can leave both employees and employers feeling resentful. The Open Transition Program focuses on respect, ensuring that employees leave on a positive note while protecting the company’s reputation.
  • The Cost of Ignoring Exit Strategies
    Ignoring the importance of employee transitions can lead to high turnover, damaged client relationships, and a negative reputation. Implementing modern job exit strategies can mitigate these risks and foster long-term success.

Chapters:

  • [00:00] Opening
  • [00:34] Introduction to Robert Glazer
  • [01:20] Problems with the Traditional Two Weeks Notice
  • [03:45] Replacing Two Weeks Notice with the Open Transition Program
  • [05:30] Addressing Employee Performance Issues Early and Constructively
  • [10:04] Organizational Culture and Open Transition Programs
  • [17:24] Structured Employee Transitions and Client Retention

More About Robert Glazer: 

John Jantsch (00:00.705)

Hello and welcome to another episode of the Duck Tape Marketing Podcast. This is John Jantsch. My guest today is Robert Glazer. He’s the founder and chairman of the board of Acceleration Partners, a global partner marketing agency and the recipient of numerous industry and company culture awards, including Glassdoor’s Employees Choice Awards two years in a row. He’s the author of the inspirational newsletter, Friday Forward. Everybody should subscribe and the number one Wall Street.

Robert Glazer (00:08.144)

Thank

John Jantsch (00:30.571)

journal USA Today and international bestselling author of five books. We’re going to talk about his latest today, Rethinking Two Weeks Notice, Changing the Way Employees Leave Companies for the Better. So Robert, welcome back to the show.

Robert Glazer (00:31.322)

Bye.

Robert Glazer (00:44.548)

John, thanks for having me.

John Jantsch (00:46.185)

So, the enemy is two weeks notice the standard practice of, of, Hey, I’m, I got a better offer. I’m giving you my two weeks notice or the other way around. You’re not working out here. You got two weeks notice. So that kind of deal. So, so why is that bad?

Robert Glazer (00:57.54)

Yeah, here’s two weeks severance. Yeah.

Robert Glazer (01:03.824)

There’s two problems that we have. Well, I’m a big fan of psychology and cognitive dissonance. And so the left side of our brains knows that we’re not in lifetime employment situation anymore. We don’t have pensions, people are going to work forever. And yet when people then leave our organization, the right side of the brain, we treat it more like the end of a marriage than the end of a professional sports contract, like this huge betrayal or otherwise. So we’re just not reconciling.

these two things and it produces bad outcomes. You have employees who leave employers and their managers and their mentors with a bad taste in their mouth. what they’re told by their parents, two weeks notice. That’s what you do, it’s respectful. But if you mentored someone for three years, you trusted them, you gave them a lot of rope and they were out a little bit and had doctor’s appointments and now they’re leaving in two weeks.

John Jantsch (01:44.791)

Yeah. Right.

Robert Glazer (01:55.874)

You don’t realize, I mean, I get a lot of back channel references over the years. Everything is layout. You’re going for a job, two jobs from now and someone reaches out and they’re like, yeah, John, like, I just remember how you left, right? And so endings really matter. If you’re planning a conference, your last speaker is really important. It’s sort of, it’s everything that people remember. And then similarly for the company, particularly in a service business, know, clients hate account turnover.

John Jantsch (02:10.486)

Yes.

John Jantsch (02:14.433)

Yeah.

Robert Glazer (02:22.436)

rushing to get a new person, all these things. it just really is suboptimal. It’s just an outdated process. Most people just don’t know what to replace it with.

John Jantsch (02:30.423)

Yeah.

Right. Yeah. It’s funny. I, you know, in marketing circles, I mean, I pay a lot of attention to testimonials and reviews and things like that. And it’s amazing how really the perception that somebody has of the brand is not the brand, but Rusty, you know, the guy that fixed their boiler, you know, or whatever.

Robert Glazer (02:50.832)

Look, anyone listening to this, if you are either personally or professionally, whether it’s accounting firm or your marketing agency, there is nothing that hurts the reputation more of a professional services firm than account turnover. It’s the thing that puts it at risk. If you’ve ever been with a brand and you get three different managers in 12 months, you’re like, I’m out. I don’t want to do this anymore.

John Jantsch (03:03.501)

F

John Jantsch (03:07.777)

Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. It was too much work to get in a rhythm. all right. So I’m just going to jump right into your concept of what would replace it. The open transition program OTP. You got to love a framework. So Robert, let’s just go there. We’re going to talk about bits of it, but maybe set the table. What is, what is your, theory about replacing two weeks notice?

Robert Glazer (03:12.89)

Yeah.

Robert Glazer (03:35.408)

Yeah. So, so it’s not just the theory because we practiced it for over 10 years and, and, but it is a theory, but it’s also, and I’ve had a lot of other leaders just with little bits and pieces who wanted to be better reached out. And look, we were building a great culture and just the two week notice thing felt antithetical to that. So we tried this concept of a transition program that said, look, when you’re ready to leave, we’ve created psychological safety, come and have an open, honest conversation with us. We will never walk anyone out the door that day if they come and have it. And likewise,

John Jantsch (03:41.185)

You

Robert Glazer (04:04.336)

our managers are gonna have honest conversations with you. And when we kind of sense that something’s not going right, we’ll see if we can fix it. And most problems, if you actually get to them earlier, they don’t become irrecoverable. If you wait long enough, then everyone’s pissed and they can’t get it. It almost doesn’t even matter what the original problem was. Now you’ve got this whole vicious trust cycle and stuff going on.

John Jantsch (04:21.921)

Yeah. Yeah.

Robert Glazer (04:26.266)

So we said, look, it’s okay, we’ll enter you into a transition program and maybe that’s 90 days, but you’re working here and you’re starting to interview and you’re communicating with your boss about that. And maybe our HR teams helping you with your resume. And we want you to be a productive alumni member. When it’s time to go, we want that to be a good outcome. And we’d rather do that and have less surprises and pay you to work here, understanding we’re gonna get some diminished capacity.

paying you severance or paying you kind of not to work or go away and blowing the thing up at the end.

John Jantsch (05:01.557)

Yeah, there’s a couple things you said there. I want to circle back to that idea that most problems are created by because we just don’t deal with them because we’re like, I, you know, an employee gets fired, but I should have done that three months ago, you know, kind of, kind of thing. And so it just really deteriorates. So, I think that’s, that’s, I think people have to realize that before they can start thinking about the open transition program, right?

Robert Glazer (05:26.768)

Right. is psychological safety is that there’s four components, psychological safety, open communication, mutual respect and commitment to be mutually beneficial outcomes. Psychological safety is the foundation of this. With it, you can have some good outcomes. it’s, we’re recording this in December. John, like if I am firing you this week, cause I am at my wits end where I was going to put you on a pip and you’re with your wits end. What the issue was probably emerged in March and.

John Jantsch (05:31.095)

Yeah.

Robert Glazer (05:55.288)

If I had really, and it emerges some performance problems, but this is the issue. Like this is like Western medicine versus Eastern. If three people have a headache and I give them a Tylenol, it might help the headache, but one is dehydrated, one’s allergic to gluten and one has a brain tumor, right? Tylenol is not a cure for that. So I talk in this book around digging to the root and there’s three common roots. Problems the employee needs to fix, problems the employer can fix and wants to fix, and then problems that.

they’re not gonna fix. So I start noticing you’re a little off in March and instead of saying, John, you gotta do better or whatever, I’m like, John, like what’s going on? And you confide in me, because I’m your manager and you might say one of three totally different things. One, you lost your childcare and so you’re really tired and distracted or you’re going through a separation and so you’re just not there. And so was like, look, John, I can help with this, we can change your hours, but this is on you to fix. And generally, if you repair that problem,

your satisfaction with work and your performance is gonna improve. The second one you say, look, the last three people that we hired were at a higher level me, higher salary, I’m doing the same work, I was promised a raise years ago, like I’m just getting really frustrated, right? And if I look at that and I say, geez, John’s right, like we kind of overlooked him. I might say he’s not and that’s a different discussion, you he wants a but he’s right. So we give him the promotion he deserves, he gets a new manager and boom, it recovers.

John Jantsch (07:13.099)

Yeah. Right.

Robert Glazer (07:21.616)

The third one, the one not gonna fix, John comes and says, look, I know you told me a remote only company and I thought I wanted that, but I’m just, missing an office. And you know, that leads to a discussion like, hey John, we’re not getting offices. Like, so why don’t we help you find a better opportunity? So each of those circumstances might’ve showed up in a performance problem, but they have totally different roots and totally different solutions. And that’s why this program can have a good outcome. If I lean in early and we’re doing this transition in the third case,

you know, in July, that’s different because one of the common objections is like, you can’t do this, people are toxic, all this stuff. like, look, John’s toxic in December because this has been going on for six months and now I’m pissed at him and he’s pissed at me and otherwise. the other objection, well, people will, they’ll steal and they’ll do this and people when they’re leaving all this stuff. And to that, I would say if you have a lot of people that are constantly acting toxic and stealing stuff as they’re on the way out of your company,

John Jantsch (08:01.569)

the

John Jantsch (08:10.229)

Yeah.

Robert Glazer (08:21.464)

Either you are really doing a terrible job in hiring or there’s something about your culture that’s making them that way. And either of those scenarios require a little bit of a deeper look.

John Jantsch (08:27.692)

Yeah.

John Jantsch (08:33.005)

Yeah, and that’s the real common idea behind the practice, right? It’s like, well, once we decided to fire this person, we like take away their computer, get them out the door, right? Because they’re going to do something bad.

Robert Glazer (08:41.68)

Even before that, I think in the three months when you know you have to fire John and you don’t, because John’s a super nice and likable guy, but he’s just not doing well, you start to distance him and push him away and sort of make him out to be a bad guy so that it makes it easier for you when you fire a bad guy. This would advocate the opposite. Like John, we talked about this John a few months ago, John, come into my office in July. Like John, I love you.

John Jantsch (08:45.195)

Yeah, yeah, yeah.

Yeah.

John Jantsch (08:59.467)

Yeah, yeah. Yeah, yeah.

Robert Glazer (09:06.81)

but you know that you can’t be a 50 % quota on our sales team for four quarters in a row. This isn’t working. Do you wanna be in sales? What do you wanna do? Can we help you do something different? You can lean into the relationship while holding the performance component there, but I think it’s better to go that way than to, your brain can’t, this is cognitive distance 101. It can’t handle that John’s a good guy and a bad worker, so I have to make him a bad guy so that I feel better.

John Jantsch (09:11.117)

Yeah.

John Jantsch (09:24.777)

Yeah. Right.

John Jantsch (09:32.653)

Let’s use a Susie for our example instead of John. Okay. So, so you have, you have a company that, helps, people create partnerships that are beneficial to their businesses. that’s, you’ve written books about that, which is a very common thing for an author to do, to, and, and.

Robert Glazer (09:36.046)

Yeah, so you know, you’re not the first person to say that, but the next example will be Suzy.

John Jantsch (10:00.801)

business owner to do to write a book that supports their, what they do, what their core mission is. You’ve written a couple, what I would call people ops books, that probably on the S on the very, very surface, you know, don’t seem like they would support your business objective. And yet here we are. So why, why, is this topic? So are you so passionate about this topic of people?

Robert Glazer (10:23.28)

It’s a great question. I think yeah, we are a marketing agency, but we’re also a services firm. And after 20 years of building a services firm, you can be interchangeable with a psychologist, right? It is every issue is a people issue. There’s never a broken widget. There’s never a broken press or a shipment that’s late with FedEx. And so I, you know, as a building organization, you know, we were discovering, I wanted to build this great culture. It required rethinking a lot of the

practices I had seen and as we kind of learned things and tested things, my purpose is to share ideas that help people and organizations grow. So I became kind of passionate about being a little bit of a laboratory and if we found something that worked, try to share it with people or companies. To me, companies and great leadership are the solutions to our problems. If it’s not clear to you in 2025 that government is not the solution to your problems these days, then to me that’s the biggest impact.

that we can all have is that one great leader and one great organization spawns off a whole legion of great leaders and go off, a horrible leader and a horrible organization spawns off a whole group of traumatized people. So that’s sort of the why behind.

John Jantsch (11:38.393)

So as I read the definition of open transition program, OTP, there’s a lot of culture in it first. I mean, I don’t think you wake up and go, I read Robert’s book and now we’re going to do this. Right. I mean, there’s, there’s a, if there’s not a culture of trust and there’s not a culture of we want you to succeed, you know, but what’s best for you. mean, how do you kind of start to change that?

in order to adopt this. Cause I think a lot of companies could not physically adopt this.

Robert Glazer (12:09.872)

No, no, actually thank you for saying that because there’s two disclaimers that I forgot to make. One is, do not read this book as an employee and go into a company with a horrible culture and say, hey, I’m thinking about leaving or whatever when they walk everyone to the door in hoods because this is not a bottoms up thing. This is a tops up thing. And as you said, if you have a, and I say it in the book, if you have a crappy culture and you have poor psychological safety, this probably isn’t going to work.

John Jantsch (12:19.159)

Yeah

John Jantsch (12:22.926)

Hehehehehe

Yeah.

Robert Glazer (12:37.136)

So it needs to be built on a foundation of that. I mean, the quickest way in an organization to really try to improve psychological safety, which is not easy, is vulnerability and feedback, right? Leaders are sharing more, they’re vulnerable, they’re real, and people see that feedback is welcome and taken and acted on, right? Those tend to be two of the main doors that open that up. But yeah, this is not…

This is actually a program for good companies and good leaders. And I’m not saying like myself, but like myself, we’re frustrated that the two week thing just doesn’t feel compatible with what they’re trying to do, but no one knows any other way. So I’ve had people ask, like, look, if my company doesn’t operate this, can I do this as my team leader? And I was like, look, there’s nothing that would preclude you from having open and honest conversations, encouraging people to come, you know, if you got to give HR

John Jantsch (13:14.583)

Yeah. Yeah.

John Jantsch (13:20.033)

Yeah.

Robert Glazer (13:34.434)

notice you can wait till four weeks and let them know.

John Jantsch (13:38.443)

Yeah, yeah. Well, you know, it’s interesting. While this is sort of a prescription for the end game, it’s actually a bit of a roadmap for how to not have as many end games, isn’t it?

Robert Glazer (13:51.536)

Yeah, you don’t, look, we even talk to people about this when they join, you know, so they feel like if I happen to make a mistake, it’s not going to be a disaster. People are going to leave, right? So the question, and it could be two years and it could be great or it could be four years. The key is just how do they not leave poorly? And how do you turn that into what McKinsey has mastered? And I think what we’ve had a lot of success with is like alumni, you know, you can have.

John Jantsch (14:00.407)

Yeah.

John Jantsch (14:19.211)

Yeah.

Robert Glazer (14:19.92)

your alumni at some point might be more than the number of employees you have. And they can either be net promoters and that distractors our alumni like McKinsey consultants who go in-house at companies and hire McKinsey. They go in-house at large brands and you know, they tend to hire us back to help with that. But that only works if they, if they left on a good note. So there’s a real long game to be played. You know, we live in the real time checking and glass door and review world. it, it, it, it, it’s everyone knows about.

scorched earth these days. Actually, people know more about it of the company that scorches earth rather than the candidate. I’m waiting for someone to build the inverse of Glassdoor. But it’s all interconnected and your brand’s kind of live out there. And if you can turn something that’s a negative into a positive, we put all this work into hiring well and culture and we’ve just totally ignored leaving.

John Jantsch (14:50.807)

Yeah.

John Jantsch (15:14.209)

Yeah, yeah, yeah, which is sort of the ultimate expression of culture, isn’t it?

Robert Glazer (15:19.79)

Yeah. How you treat someone out the door, probably the door probably said when you have nothing to gain from them, it’s the same thing. How do you, you you enter, know a lot of people interview and they always try get into a meal and try to see how they treat the help or the server. How do they treat people that, you know, they’re not trying to impress because they tend to show their true stripes.

John Jantsch (15:26.893)

Yeah.

John Jantsch (15:34.817)

Yeah,

John Jantsch (15:41.197)

Since you’ve been doing this for a while, I assume, do you actually consult with other companies to do this? I’m not sure if that’s part of your model.

Robert Glazer (15:48.816)

I haven’t, I’ve done some workshops or I do more speaking on the topic, but other than the, this is actually like, I had a lot of people reach out just from the Ted Talk and the HBR article and tell me, I went and decided to try to have one of these real conversations. It was so much better, but they didn’t have sort of the playbook. So this is the first time the sort of playbook has hit the market. And so, yeah, if there are companies that need help with it, I’m happy to talk to them about it.

John Jantsch (16:06.391)

Yeah. Yeah, yeah, yeah. Okay.

John Jantsch (16:18.765)

Well, I mean, it to me, it sort of perfect workshop, you know, kind of material. But again, I think the hard part is you got to still you got to come with the right frame of mind. This is not going to fix the wrong frame of mind, is it? Yeah. Yeah.

Robert Glazer (16:23.46)

Yeah.

Robert Glazer (16:31.554)

No, you have to have the right company and the right people and there has to be a level of frustration and understand that the behavior of the employees will focus, will inherently go around what they see. There was a company I talked about in the book years ago that had won these cultures award and talked about their culture, super proud of their cultures. When I asked them how people left their company, they said, well, people give notice and then we ask them to leave that same.

because there’s a lot of risk. So they kind of march everyone out that same day with a box. And then like, if you think that anyone else is going to give you more than like, again, you’re worried about people stealing, they’re not going to steal at 10 a.m. on the day that they give notice, they’re going to do it the months beforehand because they see and they know that you’re going to throw them out that day. it is just this classic devil you don’t know versus devil you know.

John Jantsch (17:07.533)

Yeah.

John Jantsch (17:19.575)

Yeah.

John Jantsch (17:25.345)

Have you, have you determined any sort of metrics, employee morale, productivity? know, I mean, is there, I know this is in some ways just sort of a tweak to your culture anyway, and it’s not a giant pivot. So, you know, have you been able to determine maybe even anecdotally?

Robert Glazer (17:44.314)

can tell you it’s probably saved us just selfishly outside of the, look, it’s actually created, I can couple things. It’s also allowed for Boomerang employees because they leave well. A lot of employees would like to come back, but I think they’re even embarrassed based on how the end went or they gave two weeks notice and they don’t wanna call, they assume everyone hates them. So we’ve got a couple of our best employees be Boomerang employees. So I think that’s a great.

John Jantsch (17:48.417)

Yeah.

John Jantsch (17:55.733)

Mm-hmm. Yeah.

Well, truth.

John Jantsch (18:05.719)

Yeah, yeah.

Robert Glazer (18:11.92)

effort of it and then also just client retention. Like I know that there are clients we would have lost. I know that, you know, again, how this plays out in a services firm. if, you know, Tracy, we’ll pick on Tracy now, you know, Tracy gives two weeks notice and is my account manager on an account for maybe my PR firm.

John Jantsch (18:25.879)

Okay.

Robert Glazer (18:35.002)

So she comes on the weekly call and she says, hey Bob, I’m gonna leave in two weeks and there’s gonna be a replacement. I don’t know who it is yet, but they’ll reach out to you. Like I’m gonna be kind of pissed, right? But let’s say Tracy’s on a transition program. so they decide, so they find out about this two weeks later, they do some account shuffling and they bring in John. And John starts listening on the reverse week’s call, then leading in on week three and four and then building the rapport. And then by week eight or nine,

John Jantsch (18:43.063)

Yes, right.

John Jantsch (19:00.109)

Right.

Robert Glazer (19:03.834)

Tracy says, hey Bob, actually John’s gonna be taking over from here and now I know John, I’m already comfortable with John, like you just assuage this whole account turnover problem.

John Jantsch (19:12.941)

Yeah. Yeah. We actually do that even in a sales environment. you know, a of times people contact us cause they’ve read one of my books or something. and if I’m the one that’s having a meeting with them or I’m the one that starts, you know, they want John and, and so we’ve done that all along. It’s like, no, you get the team here. They are, they’re here on day one before you become a client. So that kind of leads me to, I don’t know if this is that kind of out there, but because you’re in a services business every now and then.

Robert Glazer (19:26.735)

Yeah.

John Jantsch (19:41.525)

A client needs two weeks notice. Right. Either, either you want to fire them or they want to fire you. Could some of this apply to a better outcome, you know, when you’re going to disengage with a client.

Robert Glazer (19:55.374)

Yeah, mean, ideally anyone would want time. Similar, we had some clients who, this goes a little to professional sports. You’ve got people hitting their free agency period, right? You know they’re not resigning, they’re not dogging it, they’re playing out their current contract knowing that they’re not gonna renew the contract. And I just think that if we could take a, yeah, no, usually they have their best year. Thank you, Scott Borass.

John Jantsch (20:06.434)

Right.

John Jantsch (20:17.633)

Well, sometimes they have their best year.

Robert Glazer (20:24.272)

And this is just, I think, where we could emulate a little more and take this a little less personally. People are not gonna work at your company forever. We’re just not, if they’re under 30, you talk to people under 30, they think two years is like a good term. Like that’s like, hey, I did my two years, it was great, like let’s move on. And so that’s the reality. And we just need to update our software for the version that we’re running.

John Jantsch (20:40.833)

Yeah, yeah.

John Jantsch (20:44.941)

Yeah. Yeah.

John Jantsch (20:50.443)

Yeah. Yeah. I always kind of made a joke about the term when people talk about best practices. I’m like, well, there aren’t any better practices. Like, shouldn’t we try to do better practices as opposed to just what everybody does?

Robert Glazer (21:03.738)

Right? That’s funny. We always say at our company that we have a process for everything. And if you don’t know how to do it and you don’t have time or whatever, follow the existing process. But the goal is to upgrade all the existing processes. The difference is we want you to upgrade it for everyone, just not for yourself, right? Upgrade the software, upgrade the app. If you found a better way, do it and share it, right? Don’t, we don’t, want to be delivering a consistent service, but we don’t want it to just be consistently outdated.

John Jantsch (21:14.05)

Yeah.

John Jantsch (21:25.473)

Yeah.

John Jantsch (21:31.691)

Yeah. Well, Robert’s always great to visit with you. You are not only obviously building a strong culture at your own organization, you’re really contributing so much to the thinking on around the topic, even as a marketing company here. Here, most people think marketers are just cold blooded money grabbers, right? Just kidding.

Robert Glazer (21:57.604)

That’s salespeople.

John Jantsch (21:58.669)

That’s true. So I appreciate you taking a few months to about where can people find out more about your work and obviously more about rethinking Two Weeks Notice and that workshop that’s surely soon to be coming.

Robert Glazer (22:10.308)

Yeah, you can download the book anywhere that books are sold or audio books are sold. You can also go to robertglazer.com. That’s where all of my books, podcasts, newsletter, everything is on there. If you click on the Friday Forward Newsletter, you’ll then see a tab for rethinking two weeks notice. I have the book up on my sub stack and you can download the first, you can read the first three chapters totally free and see if it’s something that grabs you and you’ll get.

plenty of information even from those first three chapters.

John Jantsch (22:43.615)

Awesome. Well, again, I appreciate you stopping by and hopefully we’ll run into you soon out there on the road.

Robert Glazer (22:47.78)

John, thanks for having me again.

 

 

Weekend Favs January 11th

Weekend Favs January 11th written by John Jantsch read more at Duct Tape Marketing

My weekend blog post routine includes posting links to a handful of tools or great content I ran across during the week.

I don’t go into depth about the finds, but I encourage you to check them out if they sound interesting. The photo in the post is a favorite for the week from an online source or one I took on the road.

  • Beautiful.ai: Automatically creates professional, polished slides with AI-powered layouts and time-saving automation.
  • Canva (Presentations): Offers stunning templates, drag-and-drop editing, and AI-driven design suggestions for all skill levels.
  • Popi.ai: An AI-powered platform that streamlines customer support by automating queries, delivering personalized experiences, and optimizing workflows with advanced natural language processing.

These are my weekend favs; I would love to hear about some of yours – Connect with me on Linkedin!

If you want to check out more Weekend Favs you can find them here.

Solving the Marketing Leadership Gap for Small Business (Marketing Leadership as a Service)

Solving the Marketing Leadership Gap for Small Business (Marketing Leadership as a Service) written by John Jantsch read more at Duct Tape Marketing

Small business marketing can feel like an endless checklist: create content, run Google Ads, post on social media, and optimize for SEO. The advice is everywhere, but what if you’ve tried it all and still don’t see results?

If this sounds familiar, you’re not alone. Many small business owners struggle to create marketing strategies that deliver measurable growth. The issue isn’t always a lack of effort—it’s often a lack of leadership. Enter Marketing Leadership as a Service (MLaaS)—a powerful solution that bridges the gap between effort and impact by providing the strategic guidance small businesses need to thrive.

As the founder of Duct Tape Marketing, I’ve spent over 30 years helping small businesses transform their marketing efforts into a growth-driving machine. My mission has always been clear: simplify small business marketing and make it actionable.

In this blog, I’ll break down the critical concept of the marketing leadership gap and how addressing it can unlock your business’s full potential. Whether you’re a small business owner or a consultant looking to guide your clients, you’ll leave with practical steps to create a marketing system that works.

Marketing for Small Businesses: Why Leadership Matters

Here’s a truth I’ve learned in over 30+ years of working with small businesses: most don’t fail at marketing because they lack tactics. They fail because they lack marketing leadership. This is where Marketing Leadership as a Service becomes a game changer, offering businesses access to expert-level strategy and execution without the burden of a full-time hire.

Without a clear strategy, marketing efforts often feel scattered. You might have a polished website, post on social media regularly, or run digital ads—but if these efforts aren’t connected to a bigger vision, they’re unlikely to deliver the results you need.

Marketing leadership is the missing link. It’s about orchestrating your efforts so that every tactic aligns with your business goals and works together as part of a system. With the right leadership in place—whether through an internal team or Marketing Leadership as a Service—small business marketing becomes less about throwing spaghetti at the wall and more about building a reliable engine for growth.

Strategy: The Foundation

A good strategy is like a roadmap for your marketing—it keeps you focused and ensures every move you make supports your business goals.

It’s all about identifying where you can improve and connecting your marketing efforts so they work together. If you’re not sure where to start, getting expert advice can make all the difference. And don’t shy away from trying out different approaches tailored to your business. Take a step back and think about where you are now versus where you want to be—it’s a great way to spark new ideas and see the bigger picture.

Building a System

Instead of chasing the latest marketing tactics, create a system. This ensures long-term returns, not just short-term buzz. It’s like a marketing machine running constantly, bringing in new leads.

Building your marketing as an asset ensures it generates revenue instead of simply being an expense. Think of your marketing like an investment where your money can make even more money for you in return.

Marketing Leadership as a Service: The Strategic Edge for Small Businesses

Marketing Leadership as a Service provides small businesses with access to high-level strategic marketing expertise without the need to hire a full-time executive. It’s a flexible, cost-effective solution that fills the leadership gap, aligning your marketing efforts with business goals to drive measurable growth. By combining expert guidance with actionable strategies, this service ensures your marketing operates as a cohesive system, delivering long-term results instead of scattered, short-term wins.

How Small Business Marketing Has Evolved

Small business marketing has come a long way. Back in the day, it was all about print ads, direct mail, and word-of-mouth—simple but limited. Then the internet changed everything, bringing websites, email, social media, and PPC ads. Suddenly, small businesses had access to big opportunities, but it also got a lot more complicated with SEO, analytics, and content marketing to figure out. 

Fast forward to today, and it feels like everyone’s saying you need to do it all—social media, blogs, videos, ads—you name it.

But here’s the catch: without a solid strategy tying it all together, it’s just a lot of effort without consistent results. 

That’s why the businesses that succeed now are the ones that focus on leadership, clear goals, and building systems that actually work long-term. It’s not about doing more; it’s about doing the right things in the right way.

Adapting to New Challenges in Small Business Marketing

This year has been a game-changer for small businesses. Social media and other digital channels have made marketing move faster than ever. One agency owner I spoke to mentioned how tough it’s been to get new clients through referrals, pointing to a bigger need for better client experiences.

And they’re not alone. According to a recent NerdWallet report, 93% of small-business owners face challenges, with 54% citing difficulty in finding or retaining customers as their biggest hurdle. This highlights a critical need for marketing leadership to navigate these challenges effectively.

Marketing Leadership as a Service steps in as a game-changing solution, offering small businesses the strategic expertise they need to attract, engage, and retain customers. By aligning all marketing efforts with a clear strategy, businesses can turn these challenges into opportunities for growth.

Turning the Tide

Rapid changes demand adaptation to stay competitive.

Focus on four cornerstones: the 3 Cs of marketing (Customer, Competition, Company) and systems. Analyze these areas to establish marketing systems for lead generation.

Research shows 80% of customers expect personalized attention.

Creating systems involves defining steps from start to finish. Consider how leads interact with your business throughout the lead cycle.

Remember the significant impact of customer reviews on your overall reputation and word-of-mouth referrals.

Targeting Your Ideal Customer

Avoid the trap of targeting everyone. Focusing on your ideal customer is crucial for small business marketing. This targeted marketing strategy , according to SBA guidelines, improves return by focusing on prospects that fit your criteria. A well-structured, targeted marketing plan aligns efforts with returns.

Crafting Your Value Proposition

Differentiate your business. A strong value proposition demonstrates why customers should choose you over competitors.

Connect Directly and Deeply

Business cards, whether they’re physical or digital, are still a great way to make connections. Pair them with a quick, memorable intro about your business to leave a lasting impression at events or meetups.

Get involved locally by joining community events, and don’t forget to tap into online opportunities like influencer and social media marketing to expand your reach.

If you’re handling your own marketing, hire people who work well with your team. Keep up with tools and tips for things like SEO, eCommerce, and website hosting to stay on top of your game. Choosing the right tools and tech can make a big difference in how smoothly your business runs and how fast it grows.

Conclusion

Marketing for small businesses can be tricky, but it’s key to growth. The best approach? Focus on solid strategies, keep an eye on the data, and adapt as you go. Instead of chasing every new trend, partner with a leader—or a service like Marketing Leadership as a Service—to build a system for your marketing. That way, it becomes a long-term investment—not just another expense.

Small businesses have a real edge when it comes to connecting with customers and understanding what they need. By prioritizing leadership and using your resources wisely, you can hit your marketing goals and set your business up for lasting success.

Explore the Duct Tape Marketing Fractional CMO System and take control of your marketing to achieve measurable, repeatable results. Schedule a consultation today, and let’s build the thriving business you’ve always envisioned.

I know the challenges of starting a marketing agency and running a business firsthand—the endless research, the trials, the errors. It wasn’t easy, but it taught me invaluable lessons. From these experiences and over 28 years of trial and error, I developed a proven marketing system that has since helped countless businesses sustainably grow and scale.

Whether you’re a business owner aiming to grow (We’ve helped 1000s of SMBs 2x-10x their business) or an agency looking to enhance your client services (over 500 agencies globally have licensed our system), the Duct Tape Marketing Fractional CMO System can be tailored to meet your needs and boost your success. All it takes is the right strategy.

Ready to see real results? Let’s connect. Schedule a strategy session with our team today.